Podium ES modules prototype

This prototype is using Podium to build standalone fragments and composing them together into a full page. The focus of the prototype is to optimize development and serving of browser side javascript.

Though; the approach in handling browser side javascript described here is not bound to Podium.

This prototype implements the approach described under The approache for experimenting and testing.

Podium thermology

Since we use Podium here some thermology are in place for those not so familliar with Podium.

• Podlet - A podlet is a small fragment of a page. In a microfrontend architecure this would be a microfrontend. Podlets are standalone HTTP servers serving its content.
• Layout - A layout is a composition of multiple podlets (microfrontends) into a structure. This is normally one webpage which live on one URL.

Get up and running

This explains how to get up and running:

Installation and running the prototype

This prototype has five podlets and one layout. To get started, in each server directory run the following command to install dependencies:

npm install

One can now start each server by running the following command in each server directory:

npm start

Each server will then run on its own http port:

• Layout: http://localhost:7000
• Header podlet: http://localhost:7100
• Footer podlet: http://localhost:7200
• Auth podlet: http://localhost:7300
• Geo podlet: http://localhost:7400
• Image podlet: http://localhost:7500

Build assets

Each server has its source for the browser side assets located under {server-directory}/assets. Each server are though serving its browser side assets from {server-directory}/public which is not checked into this repo.

The browser side assets needs to be built into {server-directory}/public before each server can serve something usefull. This is done by running the following command in each servers directory:

npm run build

The approache

This prototype explore serving browser side javascript as ES Modules in a "microfrontend" setup. The goal of this prototype is to create a strategy for making it easy to develop in isolation but also maximize performance in such a setup.

ES Modules

ES Modules are at a stage where we can start using them. In our case (FINN.no) the amount of browsers not supporting ES Modules are around 1% of our traffic and comes more or less only from IE11 users.

There are a couple of very important aspects to know about ES Modules here:

• If a ES Module is refered to multiple times, the browser will only load it once.
• ES Modules does not have a global scope.
• ES Module import specifiers can refer to an absolute URL.

We should also be aware that legal ES Modules import specifiers only can be an absolute URL or start with one of the following /, ./ or ../.

import { foo } from 'http://cdn.foo.com/a.js';
import { foo } from '../a.js';
import { foo } from './b.js';
import { foo } from '/c.js';

In addition to this its common to use whats called a "bare" import specifier.

import { foo } from 'a-library';

A "bare" import specifier is normally used to refere to a installed library, ex from npm, which through a build step is replaced with a legal import specifier, /, ./ or ../, during development and when built for production deployment.

For more about how ES Modules work, this is a good read: https://hacks.mozilla.org/2018/03/es-modules-a-cartoon-deep-dive/

Bundling, modules and HTTP/2

The ideal solution would be if one could serve ES Modules un-bundeled.

With HTTP/1 this is not plausable due to the amount of HTTP request roundtrips but there is a theory that with HTTP/2 one can let the protocol do the bundling.

We have done some internal tests on serving un-bundeled ES Modules over HTTP/2 and what we see is that up to a couple of handfull of files, HTTP/2 does perform on the level of bundling these files into one file and serving it on HTTP/1.

Any more files above a couple of handfulls and the protocol is not efficient enough to replace bundling.

There is also an aspect of runtime performance hitting the js engine with un-bundeled modules: https://twitter.com/paul_irish/status/979867890080915456

CDN

A couple of CDNs specialised in serving javascript assets does apply some very handy techniques by redirecting semver versions to exact versions.

As an example, using the ^1 in the URL like this to lit-html:

https://unpkg.com/lit-html@^1/lit-html.js

will do a HTTP 302 redirect to the latest 1.x version of lit-html:

https://unpkg.com/[email protected]/lit-html.js

The redirect URL tend to have a Expires or Cache-Control header with a short cache time. The final URL one get redirected too has a never expire or long cache time header.

Organizational structure

In a "microfrontend" architecture the goal is NOT to mix every possible framework into a single page. Though; it should be possible to mix frameworks of similar functionallity (ex, when transiting from old framework X to new and shiny framework Y).

In a "microfrontend" architecture the goal is to isolate parts of a page and make it possible to deploy indivitual parts to production without having to deploy every bits and pice which goes into the page.

Despite that teams should be autonomous there are benefits in agreeing on some common shared parts.

For FINN.no its perfectly fine that a frontend infrastructure team, which is responsible for the overall frontend of our site, dictate some common libraries and which version of them which should be available for each of the other teams to use.

Making this work

In our set up, there will be a set of global libraries. These are libraries which is highly likely to be used by multiple podlets. As an example one such library might be lit-html. At FINN.no the frontend infrastructure team will dictate which libraries these are and what versions which should be available.

These libraries will be uploaded to a CDN as ES Modules. The CDN will be serving files on HTTP/2 and each library will have a semver major URL which will redirect to the latest version of the library simmilar to whats described under CDN.

An overview of these libraries and their availabillity on the CDN will be provided in a import-map as follow:

{
    imports: {
        'lit-html': 'https://cdn.finn.no/lit-html/^1',
        'preact': 'https://cdn.finn.no/preact/^8',
    }
}

When developing podlets one write browser side javascript as ES Modules and install libraries through NPM as usual. This way, its possible to have a totally isolated development process locally and one can be offline during development.

In other words; developers will write import specifiers like so;

import { * } as lit from 'lit-html';
import { sum } from './math/caclulate.js';

Here lit-html is a "bare" import specifier.

When a change in a browser side javascript is done and ready to be used in production, one create a bundle of the browser side javascript for the podlet by a build step.

In this build step the provided import-map file with global libraries on the CDN is taken into acount and any "bare" import specifiers in the podlets browser side javascript which match with the global libraries in the import-map will be re-mapped from a "bare" import specifier to an absolute URL on the CDN.

In other words; the above import specifiers will be remapped into the following:

import { * } as lit from 'https://cdn.finn.no/lit-html/^1';
import { sum } from './math/caclulate.js';

NOTE: We have already written a Rollup plugin for this which are in use in this prototype: https://github.com/trygve-lie/rollup-plugin-esm-import-to-url

The podlets bundle are then uploaded to the same CDN as the global libraries are located.

When different podlets are composed together into a layout we will refere the browser side javascript with one script tag for each podlet:

<head>
    <script type="module" src="https://cdn.finn.no/podlet-header/main.js"></script>
    <script type="module" src="https://cdn.finn.no/podlet-main/main.js"></script>
    <script type="module" src="https://cdn.finn.no/podlet-footer/main.js"></script>
</head>

Benefit - HTTP/2

A layout rarelly contain more than a handfull podlets. Due to this, including a browser bundle for each podlet from the same CDN in a layout matches very well with when we see that HTTP/2 perform good enought compared with bundling.

In other words; having a handfull of bundles served from a CDN over HTTP/2 perform the same as bundling these into one file up front.

This free us from making one bundle pr layout.

Benefit - Global libraries and import mapping

Due to the fact that ES Modules will not load the same script twice when refered to multiple times there are no performance issues having two bundles refering the same global library.

By doing the semver redirect on global libraries, as mentioned under CDN, we are equaling out minor versions into one common version.

In other words; one podlet can locally be developed using lit-html version 1.1.0 while a second podlet can be developed using version 1.1.1 locally, but both get version 1.1.1 in production.

There are off cause a danger here that a podlet break when executed with a different versions when loaded in production. This is though why the redirects on the CDN is scoped to major semver versions. Breaking changes should only happen between major versions and by scoping to those in the import mapping, one force developers to manually bump and test an upgrade before pushing to production.

Benefit - Traditional HTTP caching

Due to the fact that we have global libraries and each podlet have its own bundle we are able to utilize http caching.

Lets say we have two layouts on two URLs where both include a set of podlets:

• Layout A on https://finn.no
  • Includes header podlet
  • Includes matrix podlet
  • Includes footer podlet
• Layout B on https://finn.no/search
  • Includes header podlet
  • Includes search podlet
  • Includes footer podlet

When a user access layout A the javascript bundle for all podlets will be loaded from the CDN.

When the user navigate to layout B only one podlet on the page are different from the previous layout. The javascript bundle for the header and footer bundle was previously loaded and cached in the browser to in this case only the javascript bundle for the search podlet needs to be fetched from the CDN.

In other words; by writing podlets and publishing its javascript assets as bundles we get "code splitting" for free.

Benefit - Side effect free duplication when wanted

In theory, and depending on how libraries are written, based on the fact that ES Modules does not have a global it is possible to have two versions of the same library in the same layout without the libraries kicking the feet of each other.

In other words, if a layout include podlet A, B and C, and podlet A and B use new and shiny lit-html version 2.0.0 like this:

import { * } as lit from 'https://cdn.finn.no/lit-html/^2';

while podlet C are a bit behind and use version 1.0.0 like this:

import { * } as lit from 'https://cdn.finn.no/lit-html/^1';

this should not cause problems for each podlet included in a layout due to how ES Modules work.

There are though an issue of douple loading two versions of the same global library in a layout.

Future - Import maps

In this approach we are mapping "bare" import specifiers to absolute URLs during an build step. This mapping is done by providing a import-map to a Rollup plugin.

The usage of a import-map for this is deliberate due to the fact that in close future browsers will support import-maps and this mapping can be done in the browser instead of up front.

The need for doing this mapping in a build step is very likely to be obsolete.

Future - Service Workers

One of the reasons we have build Podium for composing microfrontends instead of using SSI or ESI are due to the fact that there is value in having more info about each podlet in a layout than what one can get from just including a bit of markup.

In Podium the layout know a good deal about each podlet it includes and this info can be used to automatically build service workers.

By doing so, its possible for us to make service workers which cache all assets in a layout automatically and update these automatically when a podlet changes improving further load speed.

Service worker support has to be built for Podium. It does not exist at the moment.