diff --git a/medusa/common.py b/medusa/common.py
index 46f2a33b11..322687199b 100644
--- a/medusa/common.py
+++ b/medusa/common.py
@@ -615,10 +615,7 @@ def should_replace(ep_status, old_quality, new_quality, allowed_qualities, prefe
             if new_quality in preferred_qualities:
                 return True, 'New quality is preferred. Accepting new quality'
 
-            if new_quality > old_quality:
-                return True, 'New quality is higher quality (and allowed). Accepting new quality'
-            else:
-                return False, 'New quality is same/lower quality (and not preferred). Ignoring new quality'
+            return False, 'Existing quality is allowed and new quality is not a preferred quality. Ignoring new quality'
 
         else:
             # Allowed quality should never be replaced
diff --git a/tests/test_should_replace.py b/tests/test_should_replace.py
index 484eae89f7..a360307288 100644
--- a/tests/test_should_replace.py
+++ b/tests/test_should_replace.py
@@ -74,7 +74,7 @@
         'manually_searched': False,
         'expected': False
     },
-    {  # p6: Snatched Proper 720p HDTV and found 720p BluRay, and 720p BluRay is not preferred but allowed: yes
+    {  # p6: Snatched Proper 720p HDTV and found 720p BluRay, and 720p BluRay is not preferred but allowed: no
         'ep_status': SNATCHED_PROPER,
         'cur_quality': Quality.HDTV,
         'new_quality': Quality.HDBLURAY,
@@ -83,7 +83,7 @@
         'download_current_quality': False,
         'force': False,
         'manually_searched': False,
-        'expected': True
+        'expected': False
     },
     {  # p7: Downloaded 720p HDTV and found 720p BluRay, 720p BluRay is not explicity allowed but it's preferred: yes
         'ep_status': DOWNLOADED,