Implementing Dark Mode in a Diagramming App: Challenges and Solutions

[alderg]

The rise of dark mode as a user preference has created a challenge for software developers, especially for applications where colors serve more than aesthetic purposes. In diagramming apps, colors often convey critical information, such as relationships, groupings, or categorizations. Implementing dark mode while preserving the functional integrity of these colors is a complex task. This article explores the challenges of implementing dark mode in a diagramming app and outlines a flexible solution with three dark mode options.

---

Challenges in Implementing Dark Mode for Diagramming Apps

Colors in diagramming apps are not merely decorative; they serve functional roles such as:

1. Semantic Communication: Colors may represent categories, priorities, or statuses (e.g., green for success, red for errors).
2. Layering and Depth: Colors are used to differentiate between layers or groupings in a diagram.
3. Contrast and Legibility: Colors must ensure readability, especially for text or symbols against the background.
4. Consistency Across Devices: Diagrams need to appear consistently across light and dark themes on different devices.

In dark mode, a key challenge arises in maintaining contrast and readability without altering the semantic meaning of colors. Bright colors that look vibrant in light mode can appear harsh or washed out in dark mode. Conversely, muted colors may become difficult to discern. Ensuring a seamless user experience requires addressing these issues while preserving user customization options.

---

A Flexible Solution: Three Dark Mode Options

To address these challenges, a solution with three dark mode options is proposed. These options give users control over how colors are adapted in dark mode while maintaining the app's functionality and usability.

1. Adaptive Colors for Improved Contrast

In this mode, all colors are intelligently adapted to optimize contrast against the dark background. For example:

• Light colors (e.g., yellow, pastel shades) are darkened slightly to avoid excessive glare.
• Dark colors (e.g., navy blue, dark green) are brightened to maintain visibility.

This mode is ideal for users who value contrast and readability over strict color fidelity.

2. Selective Adaptation of White and Black

This mode adapts only white and black colors in dark mode:

• White becomes black and black becomes white by using a special default color value.

Other colors, including black and white specified as their respective color codes, remain unchanged, preserving their original semantic meaning. This mode is suitable for users who rely heavily on color semantics and require minimal deviation from the original palette.

3. No Dark Mode Adaptation

In this mode, colors remain identical between light and dark modes, including the background color of the diagram. While this may reduce contrast in dark mode with the containing page, it ensures that the original color choices are preserved exactly as intended.

This mode is tailored for users who prioritize fidelity over readability in dark mode.

---

Enabling Per-Color Customization for Maximum Flexibility

To provide users with granular control, the solution allows per-color customization for light and dark modes. Users can assign distinct colors for light and dark themes, ensuring:

• Colors remain functional and meaningful in both themes.
• Maximum flexibility for users who want fine-tuned control.

Hiding Complexity in the UI

To avoid overwhelming users who do not use dark mode, the UI is designed to keep dark mode settings unobtrusive:

• Color Dialog: The dark mode color option is hidden in the advanced section of the color dialog.
• Format Panel: The dark mode color settings are concealed when the app is in light mode. Only relevant options are displayed based on the current theme.

This approach ensures a clean and intuitive interface while retaining advanced capabilities for users who need them.

---

Conclusion

Implementing dark mode in a diagramming app is a delicate balance between preserving color semantics, ensuring readability, and providing user flexibility. By offering three dark mode options—adaptive colors, selective adaptation, and no adaptation—alongside per-color customization, this solution addresses the diverse needs of users while hiding complexity from those who prefer simplicity.

With this approach, diagramming apps can seamlessly integrate dark mode, providing an inclusive and user-friendly experience for everyone.