proposal: review meeting minutes #33502

rsc · 2019-08-06T21:04:51Z

The proposal review group meets regularly (roughly weekly) to review pending proposal issues and move them along in the proposal process.

Review consists primarily of checking that discussion is ongoing, commenting on issues to move discussion along, summarizing long discussions, CC’ing experts, and accepting or closing proposals when the discussion on the GitHub issue has reached a clear consensus about the outcome.

Review also includes closing proposals that are untenable (for example, because the changes are backwards-incompatible or violate key design goals of the language or packages).

This meta-issue records minutes of the proposal review meetings as issue comments, so that they can be cross-linked easily with the relevant issues. (This meta-issue is for minutes only; comments that are not meeting minutes will be deleted.)

rsc · 2019-08-06T23:39:17Z

2019-08-06 / @rsc, @griesemer, @andybons

proposal: cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816 cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations
- discussion ongoing (no action taken)
proposal: cmd/go: add build tags for 32-bit and 64-bit architectures #33388 cmd/go: add build tags for 32-bit and 64-bit architectures
- retitled, commented
proposal: cmd/go: add package search functionality #33203 cmd/go: add package search functionality
- commented
proposal: cmd/go: automatic and partial vendoring in module mode #30240 cmd/go: automatic vendoring in module mode
- discussion ongoing
proposal: cmd/go: introduce go.gen file for //go:generate comments #33375 cmd/go: introduce go.gen file for //go:generate comments
- commented
proposal: crypto: add crypto engines #33281 crypto engines
- labeled Proposal-Crypto; discussion ongoing
crypto: implement Hash.String #33430 crypto: crypto.Hash implement fmt.Stringer and export crypto.maxHash
- labeled Proposal-Crypto, commented
encoding/json: memoize strings during decode #32779 encoding/json: memoize strings during decode?
- commented, commented on CL
proposal: errors: generalize As to all types #33473 errors: generalize As to all types
- retitled, commented
proposal: image: add generic metadata support for jpeg, gif, png #33457 image: add generic metadata support for jpeg, gif, png
- retitled, cc’ed expert
proposal: log: modify Logger struct, make it supports multi output #33454 log: modify `Logger` struct, make it supports multi output
- closed (backwards-incompatible change; easy implementation outside standard library; no evidence of widespread need)
proposal: net/url: add (Values).AddAll(key string, values []string) #33498 net/url: add (Values).AddAll(key string, values []string)
- retitled, commented
sizeof: new package with constants for Int, Uint, Uintptr, Int8, Float64, etc #29982 reflect: add constants for size of int, bool, etc.
- summarized
proposal: text/template: make "template" action accept dynamic name as argument #33449 text/template: make "template" action accept dynamic name as argument
- commented, cc’ed expert
proposal: x/tools: tool to audit diffs in dependencies #33466 x/tools: tool to audit diffs in dependencies
- discussion ongoing
proposal: x/tools/cmd/gopls: provide config option for hover documentation placement #33352 x/tools/cmd/gopls: provide config option for hover documentation placement
- discussion ongoing

andybons · 2019-08-13T20:57:09Z

2019-08-13 / @rsc, @griesemer, @andybons, @spf13

proposal: cmd/go: secure releases with transparency log #25530 cmd/go: secure releases with transparency log
- commented
- likely accept; last call for comments
proposal: errors: simplified error inspection #32405 errors: simplified error inspection
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: net/http: add constant for content type #31572 net/http: add constant for content type
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: net/url: add FromFilePath and ToFilePath #32456 net/url: add FromFilePath and ToFilePath
- asked for design doc
- put on hold for design doc
proposal: runtime: add way for applications to respond to GC backpressure #29696 runtime: add way for applications to respond to GC backpressure
- asked owners for status
proposal: runtime: KeepAlive should perhaps keep things from being moved #32115 runtime: KeepAlive should perhaps keep things from being moved
- asked owners for feedback
proposal: text/template: allow io.Reader as substitution value #29165 text/template: allow io.Reader as substitution value
- suggested design doc
proposal: x/net/nettest: add MakeLocalPipe to construct local listener and connections #30984 x/net/nettest: add MakeLocalPipe to construct local listener and connections
- commented
- pinged owners of package

andybons · 2019-08-20T20:59:47Z

2019-08-20 / @rsc, @griesemer, @andybons, @ianlancetaylor

Proposal: deterministic execution #33702 deterministic execution
- closed (no concrete change to evaluate)
proposal: cmd/go: secure releases with transparency log #25530 cmd/go: secure releases with transparency log
- no final comments; accepted 🎉
proposal: cmd/go: add build tags for 32-bit and 64-bit architectures #33388 cmd/go: add build tags for 32-bit and 64-bit architectures
- commented
proposal: cmd/go: add package search functionality #33203 cmd/go: add package search functionality
- commented
proposal: cmd/go: introduce go.gen file for //go:generate comments #33375 cmd/go: introduce go.gen file for //go:generate comments
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: errors: simplified error inspection #32405 errors: simplified error inspection
- no final comments; declined
proposal: net/http: add constant for content type #31572 net/http: add constant for content type
- no final comments; declined
proposal: net/url: add (Values).AddAll(key string, values []string) #33498 net/url: add (Values).AddAll(key string, values []string)
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: identify large changes & add more process #33670 proposal: identify large changes & add more process
- discussion ongoing
reflect: optimize v.Set(reflect.Zero(v.Type())) to not allocate #33136 reflect: add Value.SetZero
- commented
x/sys/cpu: add support for ARM #33508 x/sys/cpu -- add support for ARM
- commented
- asked owners for feedback
x/sys/unix: standardize Kevent_t Udata as integer, not pointer #32153 x/sys/unix: support for all fields of Kevent_t, EpollEvent
- commented
- reduced scope
- retitled

andybons · 2019-08-27T20:53:09Z

2019-08-27 / @rsc, @bradfitz, @spf13, @andybons, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor

proposal: cmd/go: add build tags for 32-bit and 64-bit architectures #33388 cmd/go: add build tags for 32-bit and 64-bit architectures
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: cmd/go: introduce go.gen file for //go:generate comments #33375 cmd/go: introduce go.gen file for //go:generate comments
- no final comments; declined
proposal: net: add ability to read OOB data without discarding a byte #32465 net: add ability to read OOB data without discarding a byte
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: net/url: add (Values).AddAll(key string, values []string) #33498 net/url: add (Values).AddAll(key string, values []string)
- no final comments; declined
Proposal: net/url: add Values.Decode #32634 net/url: add Values.Decode
- commented
proposal: os: add Touch to set access/mod times to current time #31880 os: add Touch to set access/mod times to current time
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments
os: allow Chtimes with time.Time{} to avoid setting time #32558 os: allow Chtimes with time.Time{} to avoid setting time
- commented
reflect: optimize v.Set(reflect.Zero(v.Type())) to not allocate #33136 reflect: add Value.SetZero
- discussion ongoing
proposal: strings: a string factory to convert bytes to string #32593 strings: a string factory to convert bytes to string
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments
x/sys/cpu: add support for ARM #33508 x/sys/cpu -- add support for ARM
- retitled
- commented
- likely accept; last call for comments
x/sys/unix: standardize Kevent_t Udata as integer, not pointer #32153 x/sys/unix: standardize Kevent_t Udata as integer, not pointer
- commented
- likely accept; last call for comments

griesemer · 2019-09-03T22:29:43Z

2019-09-03 / @bradfitz, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @spf13

proposal: cmd/go: add build tags for 32-bit and 64-bit architectures #33388 cmd/go: add build tags for 32-bit and 64-bit architectures
- declined (no final comments)
proposal: net: add ability to read OOB data without discarding a byte #32465 net: add ability to read OOB data without discarding a byte
- declined (no final comments)
proposal: os: add Touch to set access/mod times to current time #31880 os: add Touch to set access/mod times to current time
- declined (no final comments)
proposal: strings: a string factory to convert bytes to string #32593 strings: a string factory to convert bytes to string
- declined (no final comments)
x/sys/cpu: add support for ARM #33508 x/sys/cpu: add support for ARM
- accepted (taking additional comments into account)
x/sys/unix: standardize Kevent_t Udata as integer, not pointer #32153 x/sys/unix: standardize Kevent_t Udata as integer, not pointer
- accepted (no additional comments)
move mature wiki content behind Gerrit #34038 move mature wiki content behind Gerrit
- commented, waiting for doc, x/tools/cmd/godoc, x/website: move golang.org content into its own repository #29206 (referenced)
proposal: os: make the internal lockedfile package public #33974 make the internal filelock package public
- cc: @bcmills
io/ioutil: reject path separators in TempDir, TempFile pattern #33920 io/ioutil: TempFile: pattern should prevent directory traversal
- commented, discussion ongoing
proposal: add standard library package for sizes #33459 add standard library package for sizes
- commented
Proposal: net/url: add Values.Decode #32634 net/url: add Values.Decode
- @bradfitz commented
io/ioutil: TempDir should support patterns like TempFile does #33805 io/ioutil: TempDir should support patterns like TempFile does
- commented (asking for feedback on proposed approach)
runtime: make GOMAXPROCS cfs-aware on GOOS=linux #33803 make GOMAXPROCS cfs-aware on GOOS=linux
- changed from proposal to feature request
doc: restructure module documentation #33637 doc: restructure module documentation
- commented (request for feedback)
text/template: make "eq" support all comparable types #33740 text/template: make "eq" support all comparable types
- cc: robpike

andybons · 2019-09-12T21:26:10Z

2019-09-12 / @rsc, @bradfitz, @andybons, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor

proposal: add standard library package for sizes #33459 add standard library package for sizes
- commented
proposal: cmd/go: allow 'go get -u' to upgrade the targets of replacements #32721 cmd/go: allow 'go get -u' to upgrade the targets of replacements
- cc’d domain experts
proposal: cmd/go: ignore +incompatible versions as of Go 1.14 #34217 cmd/go: ignore +incompatible versions as of Go 1.14
- discussion ongoing
proposal: encoding/pem: add DecodeStrict #34069 encoding/pem: add DecodeStrict
- commented
- cc’d domain experts
move mature wiki content behind Gerrit #34038 move mature wiki content behind Gerrit
- discussion ongoing
proposal: runtime/pprof: add new WithLabels* function that requires fewer allocations #33701 runtime/pprof: add new WithLabels* function that requires fewer allocations
- summarized
- cc’d domain experts
proposal: strconv: add a version of QuoteToASCII that doesn't add quotes #34145 strconv: add a version of QuoteToASCII that doesn't add quotes
- commented
sync: add new Map method LoadAndDelete #33762 sync: Map should provide DeleteWithLoad which returns loaded value and boolean
- discussion ongoing
testing: TestMain should not require os.Exit #34129 TestMain should not require os.Exit
- commented
- cc’d domain experts
testing: add Cleanup method #32111 testing: add Defer method
- commented
- cc’d more domain experts
text/template: make "eq" support all comparable types #33740 text/template: make "eq" support all comparable types
- commented
- likely accept; last call for comments
Proposal: net/url: add Values.Decode #32634 net/url: add Values.Decode
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments

andybons · 2019-09-18T17:54:21Z

2019-09-18 / @rsc, @bradfitz, @andybons, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @spf13

proposal: context: enable first class citizenship of third party implementations #28728 context: enable first class citizenship of third party implementations
- summarized
- suggested a way to avoid an API change
- asked for comments
Proposal: net/url: add Values.Decode #32634 net/url: add Values.Decode
- no final comments; declined
proposal: os: Create/Open/OpenFile() set FILE_SHARE_DELETE on windows #32088 syscall: windows Open() should set FILE_SHARE_DELETE
- summarized
- asked for comments
text/template: make "eq" support all comparable types #33740 text/template: make "eq" support all comparable types
- no final comments; accepted 🎉

andybons · 2019-09-25T18:04:42Z

2019-09-25 / @rsc, @bradfitz, @sfrancia, @andybons

proposal: cmd/go: ignore +incompatible versions as of Go 1.14 #34217 cmd/go: ignore +incompatible versions as of Go 1.14
- discussion ongoing
proposal: cmd/go: allow 'go get -u' to upgrade the targets of replacements #32721 cmd/go: allow 'go get -u' to upgrade the targets of replacements
- discussion ongoing
proposal: context: enable first class citizenship of third party implementations #28728 context: enable first class citizenship of third party implementations
- commented
proposal: encoding/pem: add DecodeStrict #34069 encoding/pem: add DecodeStrict
- commented
io/ioutil: TempDir should support patterns like TempFile does #33805 io/ioutil: TempDir should support patterns like TempFile does
- commented
- likely accept; last call for comments
net: make Resolver.PreferGo and GODEBUG=netdns=go use Go code on Windows #33097 net: Enable built-in DNS stub resolver on Windows
- asked for more information
- cc’d domain experts
proposal: net: add BufferedPipe (buffered Pipe) #34502 net: in-memory transport
- commented
proposal: os: Create/Open/OpenFile() set FILE_SHARE_DELETE on windows #32088 os: Create/Open/OpenFile() set FILE_SHARE_DELETE on windows
- commented
proposal: runtime/pprof: add new WithLabels* function that requires fewer allocations #33701 runtime/pprof: add new WithLabels* function that requires fewer allocations
- discussion ongoing
- cc’d domain experts
proposal: strconv: add a version of QuoteToASCII that doesn't add quotes #34145 strconv: add a version of QuoteToASCII that doesn't add quotes
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments
sync: add new Map method LoadAndDelete #33762 sync: Map should provide DeleteWithLoad which returns loaded value and boolean
- commented
testing: add -shuffle and -shuffleseed to shuffle tests #28592 testing: let TestMain access and change the list of tests
- commented
testing: add Cleanup method #32111 testing: add Defer method
- cc’d domain experts
proposal: testing: add B.Lap for phases of benchmarks #33194 testing: (*B).Lap(string name, b *testing.B) for sub-benchmarks of a single process
- cc’d domain experts
testing: TestMain should not require os.Exit #34129 testing: TestMain should not require os.Exit
- cc’d domain experts
proposal: testing: automatically scale benchmark metrics in results output #33328 testing: automatically scale benchmark metrics in results output
- cc’d domain expert
proposal: x/tools/goimports: Look for .goimportsignore in modules #32928 x/tools/goimports: Look for .goimportsignore in modules
- commented
- cc’d domain owner
proposal for better string formatting #34523 proposal for better string formatting
- closed as duplicate of proposal: Go 2: string interpolation #34174
add "Backlog" milestone #34376 add "Backlog" milestone
- discussion ongoing
move mature wiki content behind Gerrit #34038 move mature wiki content behind Gerrit
- discussion ongoing
proposal: os: make the internal lockedfile package public #33974 make the internal filelock package public
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: add standard library package for sizes #33459 add standard library package for sizes
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: assert of errors #32997 assert of errors
- declined; error syntax handling is not changing
proposal: errors/errd: helper package for deferred error handlers #32676 errors/errd: helper package for deferred error handlers
- declined; author withdrew the proposal
proposal: doc: more overview of Go repo for new contributors #32741 doc: more overview of Go repo for new contributors
- commented

andybons · 2019-10-02T18:00:16Z

2019-10-02 / @rsc, @bradfitz, @ianlancetaylor, @andybons

proposal: cmd/go: ignore directories containing .goignore in file scans #30058 cmd/doc: improve performance by excluding node_modules
- commented
- retitled
cmd/go: automatically check and use vendored packages #33848 cmd/go: automatically check and use vendored packages
- commented
- likely accept; last call for comments
proposal: context: enable first class citizenship of third party implementations #28728 context: enable first class citizenship of third party implementations
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: encoding/pem: add DecodeStrict #34069 encoding/pem: add DecodeStrict
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments
io/ioutil: TempDir should support patterns like TempFile does #33805 io/ioutil: TempDir should support patterns like TempFile does
- no final comments; accepted 🎉
proposal: net: add BufferedPipe (buffered Pipe) #34502 net: in-memory transport
- commented
net: make Resolver.PreferGo and GODEBUG=netdns=go use Go code on Windows #33097 net: Enable built-in DNS stub resolver on Windows
- retitled
- commented
- likely accept; last call for comments
proposal: os: Create/Open/OpenFile() set FILE_SHARE_DELETE on windows #32088 os: Create/Open/OpenFile() set FILE_SHARE_DELETE on windows
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: runtime/pprof: add new WithLabels* function that requires fewer allocations #33701 runtime/pprof: add new WithLabels* function that requires fewer allocations
- commented
proposal: strconv: add a version of QuoteToASCII that doesn't add quotes #34145 strconv: add a version of QuoteToASCII that doesn't add quotes
- no final comments; declined
sync: add new Map method LoadAndDelete #33762 sync: Map should provide DeleteWithLoad which returns loaded value and boolean
- retitled
- commented
- likely accept; last call for comments
testing: add -shuffle and -shuffleseed to shuffle tests #28592 testing: let TestMain access and change the list of tests
- commented
- retitled
- rescoped
- cc’d domain experts
testing: add Cleanup method #32111 testing: add Defer method
- commented
- retitled
testing: TestMain should not require os.Exit #34129 testing: TestMain should not require os.Exit
- commented
proposal: testing: automatically scale benchmark metrics in results output #33328 testing: automatically scale benchmark metrics in results output
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: x/tools/goimports: Look for .goimportsignore in modules #32928 x/tools/goimports: Look for .goimportsignore in modules
- marked as duplicate of proposal: cmd/go: ignore directories containing .goignore in file scans #30058
add "Backlog" milestone #34376 add "Backlog" milestone
- commented
- likely accept; last call for comments
proposal: os: make the internal lockedfile package public #33974 make the internal lockedfile package public
- commented
- asked for design doc
proposal: add standard library package for sizes #33459 add standard library package for sizes
- no final comments; declined
proposal: doc: more overview of Go repo for new contributors #32741 doc: more overview of Go repo for new contributors
- closed; no concrete proposal

andybons · 2019-10-09T18:05:04Z

2019-10-09 / @andybons, @bradfitz, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rsc

Proposals

add "Backlog" milestone #34376 add "Backlog" milestone
- no final comments; accepted 🎉
cmd/go: automatically check and use vendored packages #33848 cmd/go: automatically check and use vendored packages
- no final comments; accepted 🎉
proposal: cmd/go: ignore directories containing .goignore in file scans #30058 cmd/go: ignore directories containing .goignore in file scans
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: context: enable first class citizenship of third party implementations #28728 context: enable first class citizenship of third party implementations
- no final comments; declined
proposal: create contribution guidelines for technical writers #33323 create contribution guidelines for technical writers
- commented
proposal: encoding/pem: add DecodeStrict #34069 encoding/pem: add DecodeStrict
- no final comments; declined
proposal: os: make the internal lockedfile package public #33974 make the internal lockedfile package public
- put on hold
proposal: issues: distinguish "blocks beta/rc" from "blocks final release" #33135 meta: add milestone(s) or labels for pre-release blockers
- commented
- put on hold
proposal: net: add BufferedPipe (buffered Pipe) #34502 net: in-memory transport
- retitled
- likely accept; last call for comments
net: make Resolver.PreferGo and GODEBUG=netdns=go use Go code on Windows #33097 net: make Resolver.PreferGo and GODEBUG=netdns=go use Go code on Windows
- no final comments; accepted 🎉
proposal: os: Create/Open/OpenFile() set FILE_SHARE_DELETE on windows #32088 os: Create/Open/OpenFile() set FILE_SHARE_DELETE on windows
- no clear consensus; declined
proposal: runtime/pprof: add new WithLabels* function that requires fewer allocations #33701 runtime/pprof: add new WithLabels* function that requires fewer allocations
- ping’d conversation
sync: add new Map method LoadAndDelete #33762 sync: add new Map method LoadAndDelete
- no final comments; accepted 🎉
proposal: syscall: define Windows O_ALLOW_DELETE for use in os.OpenFile #34681 syscall: define Windows O_ALLOW_DELETE for use in os.OpenFile
- commented
testing: add -shuffle and -shuffleseed to shuffle tests #28592 testing: add -shuffle and -shuffleseed to shuffle tests
- commented
testing: add Cleanup method #32111 testing: add Cleanup method
- commented
- likely accept; last call for comments
proposal: testing: automatically scale benchmark metrics in results output #33328 testing: automatically scale benchmark metrics in results output
- no final comments; declined
testing: TestMain should not require os.Exit #34129 TestMain should not require os.Exit
- commented
- likely accept; last call for comments
x/website: add dark (night) theme #34601 x/website: add dark (night) theme
- commented
- put on hold

Issues with NeedsDecision label

bytes/hash: rename to hash/maphash #34778 bytes/hash: unfortunate import path
- commented
net, os: Set*Deadline() expiration error should be unique, as .Timeout() is true for keepalive, etc #31449 net: document that Conn.Read/Write should return error that Is(context.DeadlineExceeded) for deadline exceeded
- commented
- retitled
- moved to Go1.15
proposal: unsafe: clarify unsafe.Pointer rules for package syscall #34684 unsafe: clarify unsafe.Pointer rules for package syscall
- commented
x/mobile: Remove gomobile dependency on gobind binary #34708 x/mobile: Remove gomobile dependency on gobind binary
- cc’d domain experts

andybons · 2019-10-16T18:00:25Z

2019-10-16 / @andybons, @bradfitz, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor

cmd/go: add GOINSECURE for insecure dependencies #32966 cmd/go: add GOINSECURE for insecure dependencies
- commented
- likely accept; last call for comments
proposal: cmd/go: be consistent about not giving tests direct access to the terminal #34877 cmd/go: be consistent about not giving tests direct access to the terminal
- discussion ongoing
proposal: cmd/go: ignore directories containing .goignore in file scans #30058 cmd/go: ignore directories containing .goignore in file scans
- commented
- left open for further discussion
x/mod: move cmd/go/internal/modfile into x/mod for go.mod parsing and formatting #34924 cmd/go/internal/modfile: Expose modfile parsing as importable module
- commented
- cc’d domain experts
proposal: spec: compile-time boolean assertions #34868 compile-time boolean assertions
- commented
proposal: encoding/binary: cache dataSize across invocations of Read and Write #34471 encoding/binary: cache dataSize across invocations of Read and Write
- commented
proposal: encoding/json: new MarshalAppender interface to make custom marshallers more efficient #34701 encoding/json: new MarshalAppender interface to make custom marshallers more efficient
- discussion ongoing
html/template: document ability to modify FuncMap after template parse by calling Funcs again #34680 html/template: add ability to combine/clone/rebind parsed html/template templates
- commented
- asked for clarification
proposal: net: add BufferedPipe (buffered Pipe) #34502 net: add BufferedPipe (buffered Pipe)
- UPDATE: final comment period extended as new title was not used in previous meeting notes
- likely accept; last call for comments
net/url: add URL.Redacted to return password-free string #34855 net/url: add URL.Mask() method that hides the password
- commented
proposal: os: add UserShell #34910 os: add UserShell
- commented
- asked for clarification
testing: add Cleanup method #32111 testing: add Cleanup method
- no objections aside from some naming comments; accepted 🎉

griesemer · 2019-10-23T18:17:53Z

2019-10-16 / @bradfitz, @griesemer

proposal: net: add BufferedPipe (buffered Pipe) #34502 net: add BufferedPipe (buffered Pipe)
- commented on new input
- removed FinalCommentPeriod label
cmd/go: add GOINSECURE for insecure dependencies #32966 add GOINSECURE for insecure dependencies
- accepted 🎉 (no new comments)
testing: TestMain should not require os.Exit #34129 TestMain should not require os.Exit
- accepted 🎉 (no new comments)
proposal: encoding/binary: cache dataSize across invocations of Read and Write #34471 encoding/binary: cache dataSize across invocations of Read and Write
- commented (added tentative code change diff and benchmark results)
proposal: create contribution guidelines for technical writers #33323 create contribution guidelines for technical writers
- commented
proposal: doc: document that Go 1.14 is last to support darwin/arm (32bit version)? #34751 doc: document that Go 1.14 is last to support darwin/arm (32bit version)?
- minor clarification to title
- commented

andybons · 2019-10-30T18:05:07Z

2019-10-30 / @andybons, @bradfitz, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rsc, @spf13

Proposals

proposal: cmd/go: be consistent about not giving tests direct access to the terminal #34877 cmd/go: be consistent about not giving tests direct access to the terminal
- commented
cmd/go: fail tests that invoke os.Exit(0) explicitly #29062 cmd/go: fail tests that invoke os.Exit(0) explicitly
- commented
proposal: cmd/go: ignore directories containing .goignore in file scans #30058 cmd/go: ignore directories containing .goignore in file scans
- commented
- declined
cmd/go: default to -buildmode=pie on Windows #35192 cmd/link: enable Windows ASLR by default or all the time
- commented
proposal: create contribution guidelines for technical writers #33323 create contribution guidelines for technical writers
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: encoding/binary: cache dataSize across invocations of Read and Write #34471 encoding/binary: cache dataSize across invocations of Read and Write
- commented
- likely accept; last call for comments
proposal: encoding/json: new MarshalAppender interface to make custom marshallers more efficient #34701 encoding/json: new MarshalAppender interface to make custom marshallers more efficient
- discussion ongoing
html/template: document ability to modify FuncMap after template parse by calling Funcs again #34680 html/template: add ability to combine/clone/rebind parsed html/template templates
- commented
proposal: net: add BufferedPipe (buffered Pipe) #34502 net: add BufferedPipe (buffered Pipe)
- commented
net/url: add URL.Redacted to return password-free string #34855 net/url: add URL.Redacted to return password-free string
- retitled
- commented
proposal: os: add UserShell #34910 os: add UserShell
- commented
proposal: runtime/pprof: add new WithLabels* function that requires fewer allocations #33701 runtime/pprof: add new WithLabels* function that requires fewer allocations
- pinged domain experts
proposal: syscall: define Windows O_ALLOW_DELETE for use in os.OpenFile #34681 syscall: define Windows O_ALLOW_DELETE for use in os.OpenFile
- discussion ongoing
testing: add -shuffle and -shuffleseed to shuffle tests #28592 testing: add -shuffle and -shuffleseed to shuffle tests
- commented
- likely accept; last call for comments
proposal: unsafe: clarify unsafe.Pointer rules for package syscall #34684 unsafe: clarify unsafe.Pointer rules for package syscall
- commented

Issues with NeedsDecision label

bytes/hash: rename to hash/maphash #34778 bytes/hash: unfortunate import path
- commented
- unblocked
x/mobile: Remove gomobile dependency on gobind binary #34708 x/mobile: Remove gomobile dependency on gobind binary
- cc’d domain experts

andybons · 2019-11-06T19:05:12Z

2019-11-06 / @andybons, @bradfitz, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rsc

proposal: cmd/go: be consistent about not giving tests direct access to the terminal #34877 cmd/go: be consistent about not giving tests direct access to the terminal
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: fail tests that invoke os.Exit(0) explicitly #29062 cmd/go: fail tests that invoke os.Exit(0) explicitly
- commented
cmd/go: default to -buildmode=pie on Windows #35192 cmd/go: default to -buildmode=pie on Windows
- retitled
- commented
- likely accept; last call for comments
proposal: runes: create new package analogous to bytes, for rune slices #34313 create a package runes with functionality similar to bytes to work with rune slices
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: create contribution guidelines for technical writers #33323 create contribution guidelines for technical writers
- closed as done
proposal: encoding/json: new MarshalAppender interface to make custom marshallers more efficient #34701 encoding/json: new MarshalAppender interface to make custom marshallers more efficient
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments
cmd/go: add go doc -json #34293 go docs in diverse formats like json instead of just plain text
- commented
html/template: document ability to modify FuncMap after template parse by calling Funcs again #34680 html/template: add ability to modify FuncMap after template parse
- retitled
- commented
proposal: net: add BufferedPipe (buffered Pipe) #34502 net: add BufferedPipe (buffered Pipe)
- discussion ongoing
proposal: net: add MarshalText/UnmarshalText to HardwareAddr #29678 net: add MarshalText/UnmarshalText to HardwareAddr
- commented
net: prefer /etc/hosts over DNS when no /etc/nsswitch.conf is present #35305 net: prefer /etc/hosts over DNS when no /etc/nsswitch.conf is present
- retitled
- commented
net/url: add URL.Redacted to return password-free string #34855 net/url: add URL.Redacted to return password-free string
- commented
- likely accept; last call for comments
syscall: ReadLink() & Utimes() arguments for access-mode & share-mode are wrong #35150 os, syscall: CreateFile() needs FILE_SHARE_*
- commented
proposal: runtime/pprof: add new WithLabels* function that requires fewer allocations #33701 runtime/pprof: add new WithLabels* function that requires fewer allocations
- commented
spec: allow embedding overlapping interfaces #6977 spec: allow embedding overlapping interfaces
- commented
- likely accept; last call for comments
proposal: syscall: define Windows O_ALLOW_DELETE for use in os.OpenFile #34681 syscall: define Windows O_ALLOW_DELETE for use in os.OpenFile
- commented
testing: add -shuffle and -shuffleseed to shuffle tests #28592 testing: add -shuffle and -shuffleseed to shuffle tests
- no final comments; accepted 🥳
proposal: unsafe: clarify unsafe.Pointer rules for package syscall #34684 unsafe: clarify unsafe.Pointer rules for package syscall
- retitled
- commented

andybons · 2019-11-13T18:55:11Z

2019-11-13 / @andybons, @bradfitz, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rsc

proposal: cmd/go: allow replace directives in go.mod to work for standard libraries #35283 cmd/go: allow replace directives in go.mod to work for standard libraries
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: cmd/go: be consistent about not giving tests direct access to the terminal #34877 cmd/go: be consistent about not giving tests direct access to the terminal
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments
cmd/go: default to -buildmode=pie on Windows #35192 cmd/go: default to -buildmode=pie on Windows
- no change in consensu; accepted 🎉
cmd/go: fail tests that invoke os.Exit(0) explicitly #29062 cmd/go: fail tests that invoke os.Exit(0) explicitly
- commented
proposal: encoding/json: new MarshalAppender interface to make custom marshallers more efficient #34701 encoding/json: new MarshalAppender interface to make custom marshallers more efficient
- commented
- no change in consensus; declined
cmd/go: add go doc -json #34293 go docs in diverse formats like json instead of just plain text
- commented
html/template: document ability to modify FuncMap after template parse by calling Funcs again #34680 html/template: add ability to modify FuncMap after template parse
- commented
proposal: net: add BufferedPipe (buffered Pipe) #34502 net: add BufferedPipe (buffered Pipe)
- discussion ongoing
proposal: net: add MarshalText/UnmarshalText to HardwareAddr #29678 net: add MarshalText/UnmarshalText to HardwareAddr
- discussion ongoing
net: prefer /etc/hosts over DNS when no /etc/nsswitch.conf is present #35305 net: prefer /etc/hosts over DNS when no /etc/nsswitch.conf is present
- likely accept; last call for comments
net/url: add URL.Redacted to return password-free string #34855 net/url: add URL.Redacted to return password-free string
- commented
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
os: allow Chtimes with time.Time{} to avoid setting time #32558 os: allow Chtimes with time.Time{} to avoid setting time
- commented
- likely accept; last call for comments
proposal: runes: create new package analogous to bytes, for rune slices #34313 runes: create new package analogous to bytes, for rune slices
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: runtime/pprof: add new WithLabels* function that requires fewer allocations #33701 runtime/pprof: add new WithLabels* function that requires fewer allocations
- waiting for information
spec: allow embedding overlapping interfaces #6977 spec: allow embedding overlapping interfaces
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
proposal: cmd/doc: add "// Unstable:" prefix convention #34409 cmd/doc: add "// Unstable:" prefix convention
- retitled
- commented
proposal: syscall: define Windows O_ALLOW_DELETE for use in os.OpenFile #34681 syscall: define Windows O_ALLOW_DELETE for use in os.OpenFile
- commented
proposal: unsafe: clarify unsafe.Pointer rules for package syscall #34684 unsafe: clarify unsafe.Pointer rules for package syscall
- discussion ongoing

andybons · 2019-11-20T19:03:17Z

2019-11-20 / @andybons, @bradfitz, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rsc

proposal: cmd/doc: add "// Unstable:" prefix convention #34409 cmd/doc: add "// Unstable:" prefix convention
- commented
proposal: cmd/go: add go test -long #34707 cmd/go: add go test -long
- retitled
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: cmd/go: add go cli version to the User-Agent string #35699 cmd/go: add go cli version to the User-Agent string
- commented
proposal: cmd/go: add go fmt -s #35258 cmd/go: add simplify (-s) flag from gofmt to go fmt
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: cmd/go: allow replace directives in go.mod to work for standard libraries #35283 cmd/go: allow replace directives in go.mod to work for standard libraries
- likely decline; last call for comments
cmd/go: fail tests that invoke os.Exit(0) explicitly #29062 cmd/go: fail tests that invoke os.Exit(0) explicitly
- discussion ongoing
proposal: cmd/vet: require explicit variable shadowing #31064 cmd/vet: require explicit variable shadowing
- likely decline; last call for comments
crypto/ecdsa: add SignASN1, VerifyASN1 #20544 crypto/ecdsa: add SignASN1, VerifyASN1
- likely accept; last call for comments
cmd/go: add go doc -json #34293 go docs in diverse formats like json instead of just plain text
- commented
html/template: document ability to modify FuncMap after template parse by calling Funcs again #34680 html/template: add ability to modify FuncMap after template parse
- commented
proposal: net: add BufferedPipe (buffered Pipe) #34502 net: add BufferedPipe (buffered Pipe)
- discussion ongoing
proposal: net: add MarshalText/UnmarshalText to HardwareAddr #29678 net: add MarshalText/UnmarshalText to HardwareAddr
- discussion ongoing
proposal: runtime/pprof: add new WithLabels* function that requires fewer allocations #33701 runtime/pprof: add new WithLabels* function that requires fewer allocations
- placed on hold
proposal: syscall: define Windows O_ALLOW_DELETE for use in os.OpenFile #34681 syscall: define Windows O_ALLOW_DELETE for use in os.OpenFile
- commented
proposal: time: Long/Short day and month names should start with Upper case to allow customization #34698 time: Long/Short day and month names should start with Upper case to allow customization
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: unsafe: clarify unsafe.Pointer rules for package syscall #34684 unsafe: clarify unsafe.Pointer rules for package syscall
- discussion ongoing

rsc · 2019-11-27T20:19:33Z

2019-11-27 / @ianlancetaylor, @rsc

all: make linux/arm64 a first-class port #35593 all: make linux/arm64 a first-class port
- likely accept; last call for comments
proposal: cmd/doc: add "// Unstable:" prefix convention #34409 cmd/doc: add "// Unstable:" prefix convention
- discussion ongoing
proposal: cmd/go: add GOMIPS64=r2 for mips64r2 code generation #35008 cmd/go: add GOMIPS64=r2 for mips64r2 code generation
- discussion ongoing
proposal: cmd/go: add go cli version to the User-Agent string #35699 cmd/go: add go cli version to the User-Agent string
- likely decline; last call for comments
cmd/go: add go doc -json #34293 cmd/go: add go doc -json
- likely accept; last call for comments
proposal: cmd/go: add go fmt -s #35258 cmd/go: add go fmt -s
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: cmd/go: add go test -long #34707 cmd/go: add go test -long
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: cmd/go: add .proxy endpoint to the module proxy spec #35400 cmd/go: add .proxy endpoint to the module proxy spec
- commented
proposal: cmd/go: allow replace directives in go.mod to work for standard libraries #35283 cmd/go: allow replace directives in go.mod to work for standard libraries
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: cmd/go: have go get... look in vendored caches for dependencies #35510 cmd/go: have go get... look in vendored caches for dependencies
- likely decline; last call for comments
crypto/ecdsa: add SignASN1, VerifyASN1 #20544 crypto/ecdsa: add SignASN1, VerifyASN1
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
proposal: database/sql: expose convertAssign functionality in an Any type #35697 database/sql: expose convertAssign functionality in an Any type
- cc’ed domain owners
proposal: database/sql: sql.IsNull #34593 database/sql: sql.IsNull
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: flag: support comma-separated flag aliasing #35761 flag: support comma-separated flag aliasing
- commented
html/template: document ability to modify FuncMap after template parse by calling Funcs again #34680 html/template: document ability to modify FuncMap after template parse by calling Funcs again
- moved out of proposal process (now a documentation issue)
proposal: io/ioutil: add WriteNopCloser #22823 io/ioutil: add WriteNopCloser
- commented
io/ioutil: reject path separators in TempDir, TempFile pattern #33920 io/ioutil: reject path separators in TempDir, TempFile pattern
- likely accept; last call for comments
proposal: log: add flag to display ISO 8601 date and time format #34416 log: add flag to display ISO 8601 date and time format
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: net: add BufferedPipe (buffered Pipe) #34502 net: add BufferedPipe (buffered Pipe)
- placed on hold
proposal: net: add MarshalText/UnmarshalText to HardwareAddr #29678 net: add MarshalText/UnmarshalText to HardwareAddr
- placed on hold
proposal: os: add function to return environment var with default value #35696 os: add function to return environment var with default value
- likely decline; last call for comments
sizeof: new package with constants for Int, Uint, Uintptr, Int8, Float64, etc #29982 reflect: add constants for size of int, bool, etc.
- commented
proposal: runtime: permit setting goroutine name to appear in stack dumps #35178 runtime: permit setting goroutine name to appear in stack dumps
- discussion ongoing
proposal: syscall: define Windows O_ALLOW_DELETE for use in os.OpenFile #34681 syscall: define Windows O_ALLOW_DELETE for use in os.OpenFile
- commented
testing: move Internal types to internal package #35567 testing: move Internal types to internal package
- likely accept; last call for comments
testing: print more precision in benchmark timings #34626 testing: print more precision in benchmark timings
- commented
proposal: time: add a channel to time.Ticker to detect stopped tickers #35643 time: add a channel to time.Ticker to detect stopped tickers
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: time: Long/Short day and month names should start with Upper case to allow customization #34698 time: Long/Short day and month names should start with Upper case to allow customization
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: unsafe: clarify unsafe.Pointer rules for package syscall #34684 unsafe: clarify unsafe.Pointer rules for package syscall
- placed on hold
x/crypto/nacl: Support for libsodium "sealed box" #35346 x/crypto/nacl: Support for libsodium "sealed box"
- likely accept; last call for comments

andybons · 2019-12-04T18:55:38Z

2019-12-04 / @andybons, @bradfitz, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rsc, @spf13

all: make linux/arm64 a first-class port #35593 all: make linux/arm64 a first-class port
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
proposal: cmd/doc: add "// Unstable:" prefix convention #34409 cmd/doc: add "// Unstable:" prefix convention
- discussion ongoing
proposal: cmd/go: add .proxy endpoint to the module proxy spec #35400 cmd/go: add .proxy endpoint to the module proxy spec
- put on hold
proposal: cmd/go: add go cli version to the User-Agent string #35699 cmd/go: add go cli version to the User-Agent string
- no final comments; declined
cmd/go: add go doc -json #34293 cmd/go: add go doc -json
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
proposal: cmd/go: add GOMIPS64=r2 for mips64r2 code generation #35008 cmd/go: add GOMIPS64=r2 for mips64r2 code generation
- commented
cmd/go: fail tests that invoke os.Exit(0) explicitly #29062 cmd/go: fail tests that invoke os.Exit(0) explicitly
- likely accept; last call for comments
proposal: cmd/go: have go get... look in vendored caches for dependencies #35510 cmd/go: have go get... look in vendored caches for dependencies
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: crypto/tls: add SetOCSPStaple function #14878 crypto/tls: add SetOCSPStaple function
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: database/sql: expose convertAssign functionality in an Any type #35697 database/sql: expose convertAssign functionality in an Any type
- discussion ongoing
proposal: database/sql: sql.IsNull #34593 database/sql: sql.IsNull
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: io/ioutil: add WriteNopCloser #22823 io/ioutil: add WriteNopCloser
- discussion ongoing
io/ioutil: reject path separators in TempDir, TempFile pattern #33920 io/ioutil: reject path separators in TempDir, TempFile pattern
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
proposal: log: add flag to display ISO 8601 date and time format #34416 log: add flag to display ISO 8601 date and time format
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: os: add function to return environment var with default value #35696 os: add function to return environment var with default value
- no change in consensus; declined
sizeof: new package with constants for Int, Uint, Uintptr, Int8, Float64, etc #29982 reflect: add constants for size of int, bool, etc.
- commented
proposal: runtime: permit setting goroutine name to appear in stack dumps #35178 runtime: permit setting goroutine name to appear in stack dumps
- likely decline; last call for comments
proposal: syscall: define Windows O_ALLOW_DELETE for use in os.OpenFile #34681 syscall: define Windows O_ALLOW_DELETE for use in os.OpenFile
- commented
testing: print more precision in benchmark timings #34626 testing: print more precision in benchmark timings
- likely accept; last call for comments
testing: move Internal types to internal package #35567 testing: move Internal types to internal package
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
proposal: time: add a channel to time.Ticker to detect stopped tickers #35643 time: add a channel to time.Ticker to detect stopped tickers
- no change in consensus; declined
x/crypto/nacl: Support for libsodium "sealed box" #35346 x/crypto/nacl: Support for libsodium "sealed box"
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
proposal: x/crypto/ssh: add package for Key Revocation Lists #22741 x/crypto/ssh: add package for Key Revocation Lists
- likely decline; last call for comments

rsc · 2019-12-11T20:20:15Z

2019-12-11 / @rsc, @ianlancetaylor, @griesemer, @bradfitz

proposal: bytes: Introduce a FindFirstMultiByteChar API #34375 bytes: Introduce a FindFirstMultiByteChar API
- commented
proposal: cmd/doc: add "// Unstable:" prefix convention #34409 cmd/doc: add "// Unstable:" prefix convention
- discussion ongoing
proposal: cmd/go: add GOMIPS64=r2 for mips64r2 code generation #35008 cmd/go: add GOMIPS64=r2 for mips64r2 code generation
- commented
cmd/go: fail tests that invoke os.Exit(0) explicitly #29062 cmd/go: fail tests that invoke os.Exit(0) explicitly
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
proposal: cmd/go: support embedding static assets (files) in binaries #35950 cmd/go: support embedding static assets (files) in binaries
- hold for design doc
proposal: crypto/tls: add SetOCSPStaple function #14878 crypto/tls: add SetOCSPStaple function
- no change in consensus; declined
crypto/tls: remove SSLv3 support #32716 crypto/tls: remove SSLv3 support
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
database/sql: add error getter on sql.Row #35804 database/sql: add error getter on sql.Row
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: database/sql: expose convertAssign functionality in an Any type #35697 database/sql: expose convertAssign functionality in an Any type
- cc’ed owners
doc: document/reassert that last two releases are supported equally #34536 document/reassert that last two releases are supported equally
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: io/ioutil: add WriteNopCloser #22823 io/ioutil: add WriteNopCloser
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: io: add NewReaderAt interface #34305 io: add NewReaderAt interface
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
math/big: add Int.FillBytes #35833 math/big: add Int.FillBytes
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
sizeof: new package with constants for Int, Uint, Uintptr, Int8, Float64, etc #29982 reflect: add constants for size of int, bool, etc.
- discussion ongoing
proposal: reflect: add mechanisms to allocate large slices only if possible #33060 reflect: add mechanisms to allocate large slices only if possible
- commented
proposal: runtime: permit setting goroutine name to appear in stack dumps #35178 runtime: permit setting goroutine name to appear in stack dumps
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: support GOOS=none GOARCH=amd64 for running Go programs without an OS #35956 support GOOS=none GOARCH=amd64 for running Go programs without an OS
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: syscall: define Windows O_ALLOW_DELETE for use in os.OpenFile #34681 syscall: define Windows O_ALLOW_DELETE for use in os.OpenFile
- commented
testing: print more precision in benchmark timings #34626 testing: print more precision in benchmark timings
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
proposal: x/crypto/ssh: add package for Key Revocation Lists #22741 x/crypto/ssh: add package for Key Revocation Lists
- no change in consensus; declined
x/playground: allow selecting supported versions of Go #33629 x/playground: support all versions of Go
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳

rsc · 2020-01-08T19:42:52Z

2020-01-08 / @rsc, @ianlancetaylor, @griesemer, @bradfitz, @andybons

proposal: cmd/go: allow && and || operators and parentheses in build tags #25348 allow && and || operators and parentheses in build tags
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: bytes: Introduce a FindFirstMultiByteChar API #34375 bytes: Introduce a FindFirstMultiByteChar API
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: cmd/go: add GOMIPS64=r2 for mips64r2 code generation #35008 cmd/go: add GOMIPS64=r2 for mips64r2 code generation
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: cmd/go: bundle GOROOT in cmd/go tool #36266 cmd/go: bundle GOROOT in cmd/go tool
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/tls: remove SSLv3 support #32716 crypto/tls: remove SSLv3 support
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
database/sql: add error getter on sql.Row #35804 database/sql: add error getter on sql.Row
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
doc: document/reassert that last two releases are supported equally #34536 doc: document/reassert that last two releases are supported equally
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
proposal: io/ioutil: add WriteNopCloser #22823 io/ioutil: add WriteNopCloser
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: io: add NewReaderAt interface #34305 io: add NewReaderAt interface
- no change in consensus; declined
math/big: add Int.FillBytes #35833 math/big: add Int.FillBytes
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
proposal: reflect: add mechanisms to allocate large slices only if possible #33060 reflect: add mechanisms to allocate large slices only if possible
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
sizeof: new package with constants for Int, Uint, Uintptr, Int8, Float64, etc #29982 sizeof: new package with constants for Int, Uint, Uintptr, Int8, Float64, etc
- retitled, commented
proposal: strings: add (*Reader).String() #36290 strings: add (*Reader).String()
- commented
proposal: support GOOS=none GOARCH=amd64 for running Go programs without an OS #35956 support GOOS=none GOARCH=amd64 for running Go programs without an OS
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: sync: add (*WaitGroup).WaitUnlock(l Locker) #36349 sync: add (*WaitGroup).WaitUnlock(l Locker)
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: syscall: define Windows O_ALLOW_DELETE for use in os.OpenFile #34681 syscall: define Windows O_ALLOW_DELETE for use in os.OpenFile
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: testing: flag show skipped #34306 testing: flag show skipped
- commented
proposal: testing: support running examples in parallel #35852 testing: support running examples in parallel
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
x/playground: allow selecting supported versions of Go #33629 x/playground: allow selecting supported versions of Go
- commented, retitled, removed likely decline

rsc · 2020-01-15T19:31:40Z

2020-01-15 / @rsc, @ianlancetaylor, @griesemer, @bradfitz, @spf13

proposal: cmd/go: allow && and || operators and parentheses in build tags #25348 allow && and || operators and parentheses in build tags
- changed back to active status
- discussion ongoing
proposal: bytes: Introduce a FindFirstMultiByteChar API #34375 bytes: Introduce a FindFirstMultiByteChar API
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: cmd/go: add GOMIPS64=r2 for mips64r2 code generation #35008 cmd/go: add GOMIPS64=r2 for mips64r2 code generation
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: cmd/go: bundle GOROOT in cmd/go tool #36266 cmd/go: bundle GOROOT in cmd/go tool
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: cmd/vet: magic comment to check that variable is stack allocated #34798 cmd/vet: magic comment to check that variable is stack allocated
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: crypto, hash: add WriteString support #14757 crypto, hash: add WriteString support
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: crypto/cipher: ability to use AEAD mode as block mode #23514 crypto/cipher: ability to use AEAD mode as block mode
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/ecdsa: make PublicKey implement encoding.TextMarshaler/TextUnmarshaler using PEM #33564 crypto/ecdsa: make PublicKey implement json.Unmarshaler and json.Marshaler
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/tls: add Dialer with Dial, DialContext methods #18482 crypto/tls: add Dialer with Dial, DialContext methods
- retitled
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: database/sql: expose convertAssign functionality in an Any type #35697 database/sql: expose convertAssign functionality in an Any type
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: net: add LookupSOA function #35061 net: add LookupSOA function
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
reflect: optimize v.Set(reflect.Zero(v.Type())) to not allocate #33136 reflect: add Value.SetZero
- commented
proposal: reflect: add mechanisms to allocate large slices only if possible #33060 reflect: add mechanisms to allocate large slices only if possible
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: runtime: KeepAlive should perhaps keep things from being moved #32115 runtime: KeepAlive should perhaps keep things from being moved
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
sizeof: new package with constants for Int, Uint, Uintptr, Int8, Float64, etc #29982 sizeof: new package with constants for Int, Uint, Uintptr, Int8, Float64, etc
- commented
proposal: strings: add (*Reader).String() #36290 strings: add (*Reader).String()
- closed by reporter
proposal: sync: add (*WaitGroup).WaitUnlock(l Locker) #36349 sync: add (*WaitGroup).WaitUnlock(l Locker)
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: syscall: define Windows O_ALLOW_DELETE for use in os.OpenFile #34681 syscall: define Windows O_ALLOW_DELETE for use in os.OpenFile
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: testing: flag show skipped #34306 testing: flag show skipped
- commented
proposal: testing: support running examples in parallel #35852 testing: support running examples in parallel
- no change in consensus; declined
time: add Ticker.Reset #33184 time: add Ticker.Reset
- retitled
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: wiki: CodeReviewComments change: Discourage duplicate imports with different names #29289 wiki: CodeReviewComments change: Discourage duplicate imports with different names
- commented
x/playground: allow selecting supported versions of Go #33629 x/playground: allow selecting supported versions of Go
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

rsc · 2020-01-22T19:06:22Z

2020-01-22 / @rsc, @ianlancetaylor, @griesemer, @bradfitz, @spf13

proposal: cmd/compile: make 64-bit fields be 64-bit aligned on 32-bit systems, add //go:packed directive on structs #36606 cmd/compile: make 64-bit fields be 64-bit aligned on 32-bit systems, add //go:packed directive on structs
- commented
proposal: cmd/vet: flag accidental integer division inside float casts #36681 cmd/vet: flag accidental integer division inside float casts
- commented
proposal: cmd/vet: magic comment to check that variable is stack allocated #34798 cmd/vet: magic comment to check that variable is stack allocated
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: crypto, hash: add WriteString support #14757 crypto, hash: add WriteString support
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: crypto/cipher: ability to use AEAD mode as block mode #23514 crypto/cipher: ability to use AEAD mode as block mode
- no change in consensus; declined
crypto/ecdsa: make PublicKey implement encoding.TextMarshaler/TextUnmarshaler using PEM #33564 crypto/ecdsa: make PublicKey implement encoding.TextMarshaler/TextUnmarshaler using PEM
- retitled
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto/tls: add Dialer with Dial, DialContext methods #18482 crypto/tls: add Dialer with Dial, DialContext methods
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto: add Equal(PublicKey) bool method to PublicKey implementations #21704 crypto: add Equal(PublicKey) bool method to PublicKey implementations
- retitled
- commented
proposal: database/sql: expose convertAssign functionality in an Any type #35697 database/sql: expose convertAssign functionality in an Any type
- no change in consensus; declined
encoding/json: allow per-Encoder/per-Decoder registration of marshal/unmarshal functions #5901 encoding/json: allow per-Encoder/per-Decoder registration of marshal/unmarshal functions
- commented
proposal: io, net: implement WriterTo for pipes #34624 io, net: implement WriterTo for pipes
- commented
proposal: net: add LookupSOA function #35061 net: add LookupSOA function
- no change in consensus; declined
reflect: optimize v.Set(reflect.Zero(v.Type())) to not allocate #33136 reflect: optimize v.Set(reflect.Zero(v.Type())) to not allocate
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: runtime: KeepAlive should perhaps keep things from being moved #32115 runtime: KeepAlive should perhaps keep things from being moved
- no change in consensus; declined
sizeof: new package with constants for Int, Uint, Uintptr, Int8, Float64, etc #29982 sizeof: new package with constants for Int, Uint, Uintptr, Int8, Float64, etc
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: strings: add (*Reader).String() #36290 strings: add (*Reader).String()
- withdrawn
proposal: testing: flag show skipped #34306 testing: flag show skipped
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
time: add Ticker.Reset #33184 time: add Ticker.Reset
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
proposal: wiki: CodeReviewComments change: Discourage duplicate imports with different names #29289 wiki: CodeReviewComments change: Discourage duplicate imports with different names
- commented
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: x/crypto/argon2: add API variants to support a buffer pool #36634 x/crypto/argon2: add API variants to support a buffer pool
- commented
- put on hold
x/playground: allow selecting supported versions of Go #33629 x/playground: allow selecting supported versions of Go
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
proposal: x/tools/cmd/godoc: GORDO enriched Go documentation format. #35947 x/tools/cmd/godoc: GORDO enriched Go documentation format.
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳

rsc · 2020-02-05T19:51:58Z

2020-02-05 / @rsc, @ianlancetaylor, @griesemer, @andybons

proposal: cmd/compile: make 64-bit fields be 64-bit aligned on 32-bit systems, add //go:packed directive on structs #36606 cmd/compile: make 64-bit fields be 64-bit aligned on 32-bit systems, add //go:packed directive on structs
- active discussion
proposal: cmd/doc: module documentation #35544 cmd/doc: module documentation
- commented
proposal: cmd/go: refine the default language version based on context #36875 cmd/go: refine the default language version based on context
- active discussion
cmd/go: add compiler flags, relevant env vars to 'go version -m' output #35667 cmd/link: Include build meta information
- commented
proposal: cmd/vet: flag accidental integer division inside float casts #36681 cmd/vet: flag accidental integer division inside float casts
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: crypto/tls: Authority Information Access support #31773 crypto/tls: Authority Information Access support
- commented
proposal: crypto/tls: add GetConfigForServer callback to *tls.Config #22836 crypto/tls: add GetConfigForServer callback to *tls.Config
- commented
proposal: crypto/x509: add support to get SSL context from certificate store on windows #23282 crypto/x509: add support to get SSL context from certificate store on windows
- commented
crypto: add Equal(PublicKey) bool method to PublicKey implementations #21704 crypto: add Equal(PublicKey) bool method to PublicKey implementations
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
encoding/json: allow per-Encoder/per-Decoder registration of marshal/unmarshal functions #5901 encoding/json: allow per-Encoder/per-Decoder registration of marshal/unmarshal functions
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: image: add generic metadata support for jpeg, gif, png #33457 image: add generic metadata support for jpeg, gif, png
- active discussion
proposal: io, net: implement WriterTo for pipes #34624 io, net: implement WriterTo for pipes
- commented
proposal: panic based error handling #36189 panic based error handling
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
reflect: optimize v.Set(reflect.Zero(v.Type())) to not allocate #33136 reflect: optimize v.Set(reflect.Zero(v.Type())) to not allocate
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
sizeof: new package with constants for Int, Uint, Uintptr, Int8, Float64, etc #29982 sizeof: new package with constants for Int, Uint, Uintptr, Int8, Float64, etc
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
proposal: strings: add (*Reader).String() #36290 strings: add (*Reader).String()
- retracted
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: testing: define naming convention for test functions #33688 testing: define naming convention for test functions
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: testing: flag show skipped #34306 testing: flag show skipped
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: text/template, html/template: add ExecuteContext methods #31107 text/template,html/template: add ExecuteContext methods
- commented
proposal: time: allow a user callback for dropped ticks #35480 time: allow a user callback for dropped ticks
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: wiki: CodeReviewComments change: Discourage duplicate imports with different names #29289 wiki: CodeReviewComments change: Discourage duplicate imports with different names
- no change in consensus; declined
x/crypto/poly1305: deprecate public package #36646 x/crypto/poly1305: deprecate public package
- commented
x/crypto/ssh/terminal: move all APIs to x/term and deprecate #31044 x/crypto/ssh/terminal: move all APIs to x/term and deprecate
- commented
proposal: x/tools/cmd/godoc: GORDO enriched Go documentation format. #35947 x/tools/cmd/godoc: GORDO enriched Go documentation format.
- no change in consensus; declined

rsc · 2020-02-12T19:26:41Z

2020-02-12 / @rsc, @bradfitz, @andybons

proposal: cmd/go: allow && and || operators and parentheses in build tags #25348 allow && and || operators and parentheses in build tags
- commented
proposal: cmd/compile: make 64-bit fields be 64-bit aligned on 32-bit systems, add //go:packed directive on structs #36606 cmd/compile: make 64-bit fields be 64-bit aligned on 32-bit systems, add //go:packed directive on structs
- discussion ongoing
proposal: cmd/doc: add "// Unstable:" prefix convention #34409 cmd/doc: add "// Unstable:" prefix convention
- discussion ongoing
proposal: cmd/go: refine the default language version based on context #36875 cmd/go: refine the default language version based on context
- put on hold
cmd/go: add compiler flags, relevant env vars to 'go version -m' output #35667 cmd/link: Include build meta information
- commented
proposal: cmd/vet: flag accidental integer division inside float casts #36681 cmd/vet: flag accidental integer division inside float casts
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: crypto/cipher: Specify nonce and tag sizes for GCM #34594 crypto/cipher: Specify nonce and tag sizes for GCM
- commented
crypto/elliptic: automatically upgrade CurveParams for known curves and deprecate custom ones #34648 crypto/elliptic: automatically upgrade CurveParams for known curves and deprecate custom ones
- discussion ongoing
crypto/elliptic: handle compressed formats in new MarshalCompressed, UnmarshalCompressed #34105 crypto/elliptic: handle compressed formats in new MarshalCompressed, UnmarshalCompressed
- commented
crypto/tls: expose names for CurveID and SignatureScheme #35499 crypto/tls expose names for CurveID and SignatureScheme
- commented
proposal: crypto/tls: Authority Information Access support #31773 crypto/tls: Authority Information Access support
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: crypto/tls: Export list of Supported TLS Client Extensions #36337 crypto/tls: Export list of Supported TLS Client Extensions
- commented
proposal: crypto/tls: add GetConfigForServer callback to *tls.Config #22836 crypto/tls: add GetConfigForServer callback to *tls.Config
- discussion ongoing
crypto/x509: add API to create RFC-compliant CRLs #35428 crypto/x509: add API to create RFC-compliant CRLs
- commented
proposal: crypto/x509: add support to get SSL context from certificate store on windows #23282 crypto/x509: add support to get SSL context from certificate store on windows
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: crypto/x509: implement TextMarshaler for *Certificate #33888 crypto/x509: implement TextMarshaler for *Certificate
- commented
crypto/x509: parse additional fields in CertificateRequest #37172 crypto/x509: parse additional fields in CertificateRequest
- commented
crypto: add Equal(PublicKey) bool method to PublicKey implementations #21704 crypto: add Equal(PublicKey) bool method to PublicKey implementations
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto: implement Hash.String #33430 crypto: implement Hash.String
- commented
encoding/json: allow per-Encoder/per-Decoder registration of marshal/unmarshal functions #5901 encoding/json: allow per-Encoder/per-Decoder registration of marshal/unmarshal functions
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
proposal: image: add generic metadata support for jpeg, gif, png #33457 image: add generic metadata support for jpeg, gif, png
- discussion ongoing
proposal: io, net: implement WriterTo for pipes #34624 io, net: implement WriterTo for pipes
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
net/http: mention Context and Client.Do in docs for Get, Head, Post, PostForm #35562 net/http: add new Context taking/suffixed helper functions for {Get, Head, Post, PostForm}
- commented
crypto: new assembly policy #37168 new cryptographic assembly policy
- commented
proposal: package tools #37166 package tools
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: panic based error handling #36189 panic based error handling
- no change in consensus; declined
runtime: panicmem should expose the address it's panicking about. #37023 runtime: panicmem should expose the address it's panicking about.
- commented
runtime: provide centralized facility for managing (c)go pointer handles #37033 runtime: provide centralized facility for managing (c)go pointer handles
- commented
proposal: testing: define naming convention for test functions #33688 testing: define naming convention for test functions
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: text/template, html/template: add ExecuteContext methods #31107 text/template,html/template: add ExecuteContext methods
- commented
proposal: time: allow a user callback for dropped ticks #35480 time: allow a user callback for dropped ticks
- no change in consensus; declined
x/crypto/acme/autocert: Enable custom port / IP binding #29540 x/crypto/acme/autocert: Enable custom port / IP binding
- commented
proposal: x/crypto/argon2: support secret value and associated data #35481 x/crypto/argon2: support secret value and associated data
- commented
x/crypto/poly1305: deprecate public package #36646 x/crypto/poly1305: deprecate public package
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
x/crypto/ssh/terminal: move all APIs to x/term and deprecate #31044 x/crypto/ssh/terminal: move all APIs to x/term and deprecate
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
x/crypto/ssh: add methods to marshal private keys to the OpenSSH format #37132 x/crypto/ssh: add methods to marshal private keys to the OpenSSH format
- commented

rsc · 2020-02-26T19:12:57Z

2020-02-26 / @rsc, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @bradfitz, @andybons

cmd/go: add GOMODCACHE #34527 cmd/go: add GOMODCACHE
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: add compiler flags, relevant env vars to 'go version -m' output #35667 cmd/go: add compiler flags, relevant env vars to 'go version -m' output
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
cmd/go: invalidate cache entries for test runs using different timeouts #36134 cmd/go: invalidate cache entries for test runs using different timeouts
- commented
cmd/go: module graph pruning and lazy module loading #36460 cmd/go: lazy module loading
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: stamp git/vcs current HEAD hash/commit hash/dirty bit in binaries #37475 cmd/go: stamp git/vcs current HEAD hash/commit hash/dirty bit in binaries
- discussion ongoing
proposal: cmd/gofmt: minimize adjacent whitespace changes on struct layout edits #37399 cmd/gofmt: minimize adjacent whitespace changes on struct layout edits
- closed (infeasible, conflicts with core design)
proposal: crypto/cipher: Specify nonce and tag sizes for GCM #34594 crypto/cipher: Specify nonce and tag sizes for GCM
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/elliptic: automatically upgrade CurveParams for known curves and deprecate custom ones #34648 crypto/elliptic: automatically upgrade CurveParams for known curves and deprecate custom ones
- commented
crypto/elliptic: handle compressed formats in new MarshalCompressed, UnmarshalCompressed #34105 crypto/elliptic: handle compressed formats in new MarshalCompressed, UnmarshalCompressed
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/tls: expose names for CurveID and SignatureScheme #35499 crypto/tls expose names for CurveID and SignatureScheme
- commented
proposal: crypto/tls: Authority Information Access support #31773 crypto/tls: Authority Information Access support
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: crypto/tls: Export list of Supported TLS Client Extensions #36337 crypto/tls: Export list of Supported TLS Client Extensions
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/tls: add Config.VerifyConnection callback #36736 crypto/tls: Provide access to stapled OCSP response in VerifyPeerCertificate callback
- commented
proposal: crypto/tls: add GetConfigForServer callback to *tls.Config #22836 crypto/tls: add GetConfigForServer callback to *tls.Config
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/x509: add API to create RFC-compliant CRLs #35428 crypto/x509: add API to create RFC-compliant CRLs
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: crypto/x509: add support to get SSL context from certificate store on windows #23282 crypto/x509: add support to get SSL context from certificate store on windows
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: crypto/x509: implement TextMarshaler for *Certificate #33888 crypto/x509: implement TextMarshaler for *Certificate
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
crypto: implement Hash.String #33430 crypto: implement Hash.String
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: io: default ByteReader from Reader #37344 default implementation of io.ByteReader from io.Reader
- commented
proposal: exec: add (*Cmd).ExtraInPipe and ExtraOutPipe #37094 exec: add (*Cmd).ExtraInPipe and ExtraOutPipe
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: image: add generic metadata support for jpeg, gif, png #33457 image: add generic metadata support for jpeg, gif, png
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: io, net: implement WriterTo for pipes #34624 io, net: implement WriterTo for pipes
- no change in consensus; declined
net/http: mention Context and Client.Do in docs for Get, Head, Post, PostForm #35562 net/http: mention Context and Client.Do in docs for Get, Head, Post, PostForm
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
crypto: new assembly policy #37168 new cryptographic assembly policy
- discussion ongoing
proposal: package tools #37166 package tools
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: runtime: add a mechanism for specifying a minimum target heap size #23044 runtime: add a mechanism for specifying a minimum target heap size
- closed as duplicate of proposal: runtime: add way for applications to respond to GC backpressure #29696.
proposal: runtime: mechanism for monitoring system memory #37452 runtime: mechanism for monitoring system memory
- closed as duplicate of proposal: runtime: add way for applications to respond to GC backpressure #29696.
runtime: panicmem should expose the address it's panicking about. #37023 runtime: panicmem should expose the address it's panicking about.
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
runtime: provide centralized facility for managing (c)go pointer handles #37033 runtime: provide centralized facility for managing (c)go pointer handles
- commented
proposal: text/template, html/template: add ExecuteContext methods #31107 text/template,html/template: add ExecuteContext methods
- discussion ongoing
x/crypto/acme/autocert: Enable custom port / IP binding #29540 x/crypto/acme/autocert: Enable custom port / IP binding
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: x/crypto/argon2: support secret value and associated data #35481 x/crypto/argon2: support secret value and associated data
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
x/crypto/poly1305: deprecate public package #36646 x/crypto/poly1305: deprecate public package
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
x/crypto/ssh/terminal: move all APIs to x/term and deprecate #31044 x/crypto/ssh/terminal: move all APIs to x/term and deprecate
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
x/crypto/ssh: add methods to marshal private keys to the OpenSSH format #37132 x/crypto/ssh: add methods to marshal private keys to the OpenSSH format
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
x/crypto/ssh: support RSA SHA-2 host key signatures #37278 x/crypto/ssh: support RSA SHA-2 host key signatures
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

rsc · 2020-03-04T19:34:03Z

2020-03-04 / @rsc, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @bradfitz, @spf13

proposal: all: add bare metal ARM support #37503 all: add bare metal ARM support
- commented
proposal: cmd/compile: make 64-bit fields be 64-bit aligned on 32-bit systems, add //go:packed directive on structs #36606 cmd/compile: make 64-bit fields be 64-bit aligned on 32-bit systems, add //go:packed directive on structs
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: add GOMODCACHE #34527 cmd/go: add GOMODCACHE
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: add compiler flags, relevant env vars to 'go version -m' output #35667 cmd/go: add compiler flags, relevant env vars to 'go version -m' output
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
cmd/go: deprecate -insecure on go get #37519 cmd/go: deprecate -insecure on go get
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: invalidate cache entries for test runs using different timeouts #36134 cmd/go: invalidate cache entries for test runs using different timeouts
- evicted
cmd/go: module graph pruning and lazy module loading #36460 cmd/go: lazy module loading
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: reserve example/ and test/ as non-stdlib path prefixes #37641 cmd/go: reserve specific path prefixes for local (user-defined) modules
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: stamp git/vcs current HEAD hash/commit hash/dirty bit in binaries #37475 cmd/go: stamp git/vcs current HEAD hash/commit hash/dirty bit in binaries
- discussion ongoing
proposal: cmd/go: subcommands to add and remove modules from the module cache #28835 cmd/go: subcommands to add and remove modules from the module cache
- discussion ongoing
proposal: crypto/cipher: Specify nonce and tag sizes for GCM #34594 crypto/cipher: Specify nonce and tag sizes for GCM
- no change in consensus; declined
crypto/elliptic: automatically upgrade CurveParams for known curves and deprecate custom ones #34648 crypto/elliptic: automatically upgrade CurveParams for known curves and deprecate custom ones
- cc’ed owners
crypto/elliptic: handle compressed formats in new MarshalCompressed, UnmarshalCompressed #34105 crypto/elliptic: handle compressed formats in new MarshalCompressed, UnmarshalCompressed
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto/tls: expose names for CurveID and SignatureScheme #35499 crypto/tls expose names for CurveID and SignatureScheme
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: crypto/tls: Export list of Supported TLS Client Extensions #36337 crypto/tls: Export list of Supported TLS Client Extensions
- no change in consensus; declined
crypto/tls: add Config.VerifyConnection callback #36736 crypto/tls: add Config.VerifyConnection callback
- discussion ongoing
proposal: crypto/tls: add GetConfigForServer callback to *tls.Config #22836 crypto/tls: add GetConfigForServer callback to *tls.Config
- no change in consensus; declined
crypto/x509: add API to create RFC-compliant CRLs #35428 crypto/x509: add API to create RFC-compliant CRLs
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
proposal: crypto/x509: implement TextMarshaler for *Certificate #33888 crypto/x509: implement TextMarshaler for *Certificate
- no change in consensus; declined
crypto/x509: parse additional fields in CertificateRequest #37172 crypto/x509: parse additional fields in CertificateRequest
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
crypto: implement Hash.String #33430 crypto: implement Hash.String
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto: new assembly policy #37168 crypto: new assembly policy
- discussion ongoing
proposal: errors: add new function Temporary(error) bool #37250 errors: add new function Temporary(error) bool
- discussion ongoing
proposal: exec: add (*Cmd).ExtraInPipe and ExtraOutPipe #37094 exec: add (*Cmd).ExtraInPipe and ExtraOutPipe
- no change in consensus; declined
flag: exit 0 for default -h/-help option #37533 flag: exit 0 for default -h/-help option
- cc’ed owners
- commented
proposal: image: add generic metadata support for jpeg, gif, png #33457 image: add generic metadata support for jpeg, gif, png
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: io: default ByteReader from Reader #37344 io: default ByteReader from Reader
- discussion ongoing
net/http: mention Context and Client.Do in docs for Get, Head, Post, PostForm #35562 net/http: mention Context and Client.Do in docs for Get, Head, Post, PostForm
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
os/signal: add NotifyContext function #37255 os/signal: add WithContext function
- discussion ongoing
proposal: runtime/pprof: add PMU-based profiles #36821 runtime/pprof: add PMU-based profiles
- cc’ed owners
time: add ExternalNow, etc for external time and timers #36141 runtime: "real time" timer semantics
- discussion ongoing
runtime: API for unstable metrics #37112 runtime: API for unstable metrics
- discussion ongoing
proposal: runtime: make print/println print interfaces #37642 runtime: make print/println print interfaces
- commented
runtime: panicmem should expose the address it's panicking about. #37023 runtime: panicmem should expose the address it's panicking about.
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
runtime: provide centralized facility for managing (c)go pointer handles #37033 runtime: provide centralized facility for managing (c)go pointer handles
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: sort: add InvertSlice #36887 sort: add InvertSlice
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
proposal: text/template, html/template: add ExecuteContext methods #31107 text/template,html/template: add ExecuteContext methods
- commented
proposal: wiki: CodeReviewComments change #37495 wiki: CodeReviewComments change
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
x/crypto/acme/autocert: Enable custom port / IP binding #29540 x/crypto/acme/autocert: Enable custom port / IP binding
- no change in consensus; declined
proposal: x/crypto/argon2: support secret value and associated data #35481 x/crypto/argon2: support secret value and associated data
- no change in consensus; declined
x/crypto/ssh: add methods to marshal private keys to the OpenSSH format #37132 x/crypto/ssh: add methods to marshal private keys to the OpenSSH format
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
x/crypto/ssh: support RSA SHA-2 host key signatures #37278 x/crypto/ssh: support RSA SHA-2 host key signatures
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

rsc · 2024-05-01T14:26:06Z

There's no proposal review this week; back next week.

rsc · 2024-05-08T21:26:28Z

2024-05-08 / @aclements, @adonovan, @bradfitz, @cherrymui, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rolandshoemaker, @rsc

Discussions (not yet proposals)

encoding/json/v2 #63397
gonew: templates for new modules #61669
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
metrics for the standard library #61638
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182

Accepted

encoding/binary: add func Append #60023
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
go/types: add iterator methods #66626
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
net/http: delete inappropriate headers in func Error #66343
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
structs: add HostLayout "directive" type #66408
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
x/crypto/ssh: add BannerError #64962
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
x/tools/go/analysis: add Pass.Module field #66315
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

math/rand/v2: add Rand.Read #65562
- duplicate of math/rand/v2: add ChaCha8.Read #67059
net/http: StripPrefix for path patterns #64909
- declined as infeasible
net/http: add PatternContextKey package variable to track routing #61551
- duplicate of net/http: expose matched pattern in Request #66405

Likely Accept

cmd/go: add go telemetry subcommand #67111
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/ecdsa: generate RFC 6979 signatures if rand is nil #64802
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/tls: implement and enable X25519Kyber768Draft00 #67061
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/tls: set Certificate.Leaf from [Load]X509KeyPair #67065
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
go/ast: add DepthFirst iterator #66339
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
go/types: add Alias parameter methods #67143
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
math/rand/v2: add ChaCha8.Read #67059
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
net/http: expose matched pattern in Request #66405
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
runtime/debug.SetCrashOuptut: add Options parameter #67182
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
testing: normalize line endings in example output comparisons #51269
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
text/template: range over func and int #66107
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

cmd/go: notify about newer major versions #40323
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
net/http/httptest: add support for http.ResponseController to ResponseRecorder #60229
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳

Active

cmd/go: enable GOCACHEPROG by default #64876
- discussion ongoing
cmd/test2json: Allow Go Tests to Pass Metadata #43936
- discussion ongoing
cmd/vet: report printf calls with non-const format and no args #60529
- commented
compress/zstd: add new package #62513
- discussion ongoing
crypto/rand: add String #67057
- added to minutes
crypto/tls: allow 256kB certificate messages #50773
- commented
crypto/tls: support kernel-provided TLS #44506
- discussion ongoing
errors: add All and AllAs iterators #66455
- commented
io/fs: add SymlinkFS interface #49580
- active
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- waiting on implementation experience
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- commented
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing
x/net/http2: add Framer.WriteDataN method #66655
- commented
x/oauth2: add Token.ExpiresIn struct field #61417
- discussion ongoing
x/tools/go/analysis: identify test-only packages #65749
- discussion ongoing
x/tools/go/ssa: defer into stack frame #66601
- discussion ongoing
x/tools/go/types/typeutil: add TypeMap[V] #67161
- added to minutes

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation

rsc · 2024-05-15T18:28:27Z

2024-05-15 / @aclements, @adonovan, @andybons, @cherrymui, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rolandshoemaker, @rsc

Discussions (not yet proposals)

encoding/json/v2 #63397
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
gonew: templates for new modules #61669
metrics for the standard library #61638
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182

Accepted

cmd/go: add go telemetry subcommand #67111
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto/ecdsa: generate RFC 6979 signatures if rand is nil #64802
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto/tls: implement and enable X25519Kyber768Draft00 #67061
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto/tls: set Certificate.Leaf from [Load]X509KeyPair #67065
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
go/ast: add Preorder iterator #66339
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
go/types: add Alias parameter methods #67143
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
math/rand/v2: add ChaCha8.Read #67059
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
net/http: expose matched pattern in Request #66405
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
runtime/debug: add SetCrashOutput options #67182
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
testing: normalize line endings in example output comparisons #51269
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
text/template: range over func and int #66107
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

cmd/go: notify about newer major versions #40323
- no change in consensus; declined
net/http/httptest: add support for http.ResponseController to ResponseRecorder #60229
- no change in consensus; declined

Likely Accept

all: require Linux 3.17 kernel for Go 1.24 #67001
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
cmd/vet: report printf calls with non-const format and no args #60529
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/tls: make 3DES opt-in #66214
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
encoding: add AppendText and AppendBinary #62384
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
reflect: add TypeAssert #62121
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
x/tools/go/ssa: defer into stack frame #66601
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

none

Active

cmd/go: enable GOCACHEPROG by default #64876
- discussion ongoing
cmd/test2json: Allow Go Tests to Pass Metadata #43936
- discussion ongoing
compress/zstd: add new package #62513
- discussion ongoing
crypto/rand: add String #67057
- discussion ongoing
crypto/rand: crash process on error reading randomness #66821
- commented
crypto/tls: allow 256kB certificate messages #50773
- removed from proposal process
crypto/tls: support kernel-provided TLS #44506
- discussion ongoing
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- added to minutes
errors: add All and AllAs iterators #66455
- commented
hash/maphash: add func Comparable #54670
- added to minutes
io/fs: add SymlinkFS interface #49580
- discussion ongoing
math/rand: make global Seed a no-op #67273
- added to minutes
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- waiting on implementation experience
runtime: add WaitIdle function #65336
- added to minutes
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- commented
spec: allow range-over-func to omit iteration variables #65236
- added to minutes
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
time: optimize algorithms by restricting valid year range #63844
- added to minutes
x/crypto/ssh: allow to change allowed authentication methods #66815
- added to minutes
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- commented
x/oauth2: add Token.ExpiresIn struct field #61417
- discussion ongoing
x/tools/go/analysis: identify test-only packages #65749
- discussion ongoing

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
x/tools/go/types/typeutil: add TypeMap[V] #67161
- hold for more thought

rsc · 2024-05-23T18:39:22Z

2024-05-23 / @aclements, @adonovan, @andybons, @cherrymui, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rolandshoemaker, @rsc

Discussions (not yet proposals)

encoding/json/v2 #63397
gonew: templates for new modules #61669
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
metrics for the standard library #61638
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182

Accepted

all: require Linux 3.17 kernel for Go 1.24 #67001
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
cmd/vet: report printf calls with non-const format and no args #60529
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto/tls: make 3DES opt-in #66214
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
encoding: add AppendText and AppendBinary #62384
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
reflect: add TypeAssert #62121
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
x/tools/go/ssa: defer into stack frame #66601
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

cmd/vet: enable nilness checker by default #59714
- declined as infeasible

Likely Accept

x/net/http2: add Framer.WriteDataN method #66655
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

time: optimize algorithms by restricting valid year range #63844
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳

Active

cmd/go: enable GOCACHEPROG by default #64876
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: list deprecations and newer available major, minor versions #67420
- added to minutes
cmd/test2json: Allow Go Tests to Pass Metadata #43936
- discussion ongoing
compress/zstd: add new package #62513
- discussion ongoing
crypto/rand: add String #67057
- discussion ongoing
crypto/tls: support kernel-provided TLS #44506
- discussion ongoing
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
errors: add All and AllAs iterators #66455
- discussion ongoing
hash/maphash: add func Comparable #54670
- added to minutes
io/fs: add SymlinkFS interface #49580
- discussion ongoing
math/rand: make global Seed a no-op #67273
- discussion ongoing
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- waiting on implementation experience
runtime: add WaitIdle function #65336
- commented
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- discussion ongoing
spec: allow range-over-func to omit iteration variables #65236
- discussion ongoing
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- added to minutes
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
testing: add TB.Chdir #62516
- commented
testing: add testing.T.Volatile to exempt test functions from result caching #67568
- added to minutes
x/crypto/ssh: allow to change allowed authentication methods #66815
- commented
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- commented
x/oauth2: add Token.ExpiresIn struct field #61417
- discussion ongoing
x/tools/go/analysis: identify test-only packages #65749
- commented

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
x/tools/go/types/typeutil: add TypeMap[V] #67161
- put on hold

rsc · 2024-05-30T16:37:45Z

2024-05-29 / @aclements, @adonovan, @bradfitz, @cherrymui, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rolandshoemaker, @rsc

Discussions (not yet proposals)

encoding/json/v2 #63397
gonew: templates for new modules #61669
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
metrics for the standard library #61638
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182

Accepted

x/net/http2: add Framer.WriteDataN method #66655
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

time: optimize algorithms by restricting valid year range #63844
- no change in consensus; declined

Likely Accept

crypto/rand: crash process on error reading randomness #66821
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

runtime: add WaitIdle function #65336
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
testing: add testing.T.Volatile to exempt test functions from result caching #67568
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳

Active

cmd/go: enable GOCACHEPROG by default #64876
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: list deprecations and newer available major, minor versions #67420
- discussion ongoing
cmd/test2json: Allow Go Tests to Pass Metadata #43936
- discussion ongoing
cmd/vet: consider reporting invalid/ignored Go versions in build tags #64127
- approve
compress/zstd: add new package #62513
- discussion ongoing
crypto/rand: add String #67057
- discussion ongoing
crypto/tls: support kernel-provided TLS #44506
- discussion ongoing
crypto/x509: generate serial number for nil template SerialNumber #67675
- added to minutes
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
errors: add All and AllAs iterators #66455
- discussion ongoing
hash/maphash: add func Comparable #54670
- commented
io/fs: add SymlinkFS interface #49580
- discussion ongoing
os: safer file open functions #67002
- added to minutes
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- waiting on implementation experience
spec: allow range-over-func to omit iteration variables #65236
- discussion ongoing
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- discussion ongoing
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
testing: add TB.Chdir #62516
- discussion ongoing
x/crypto/ssh: allow to change allowed authentication methods #66815
- commented
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing
x/oauth2: add Token.ExpiresIn struct field #61417
- discussion ongoing
x/sys: add unsafe mmap #56123
- added to minutes
x/tools/go/analysis: identify test-only packages #65749
- commented

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- hold for Microsoft
x/tools/go/types/typeutil: add TypeMap[V] #67161
- put on hold

rsc · 2024-06-05T18:40:34Z

2024-06-05 / @aclements, @adonovan, @andybons, @bradfitz, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rolandshoemaker, @rsc

Discussions (not yet proposals)

net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
encoding/json/v2 #63397
gonew: templates for new modules #61669
metrics for the standard library #61638

Accepted

cmd/vet: consider reporting invalid/ignored Go versions in build tags #64127
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto/rand: crash process on error reading randomness #66821
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

runtime: add WaitIdle function #65336
- no change in consensus; declined
testing: add testing.T.Volatile to exempt test functions from result caching #67568
- no change in consensus; declined

Likely Accept

math/rand: make global Seed a no-op #67273
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
x/crypto/ssh: allow to change allowed authentication methods #66815
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

none

Active

cmd/go: enable GOCACHEPROG by default #64876
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: list deprecations and newer available major, minor versions #67420
- commented
cmd/test2json: Allow Go Tests to Pass Metadata #43936
- discussion ongoing
compress/zstd: add new package #62513
- discussion ongoing
crypto/rand: add String #67057
- discussion ongoing
crypto/tls: support kernel-provided TLS #44506
- commented
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
errors: add All and AllAs iterators #66455
- discussion ongoing
io/fs: add SymlinkFS interface #49580
- discussion ongoing
os: safer file open functions #67002
- discussion ongoing
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- waiting on implementation experience
spec: allow range-over-func to omit iteration variables #65236
- commented
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- discussion ongoing
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
testing: add TB.Chdir #62516
- discussion ongoing
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing
x/oauth2: add Token.ExpiresIn struct field #61417
- discussion ongoing
x/tools/go/analysis: identify test-only packages #65749
- commented

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- hold for Microsoft
x/tools/go/types/typeutil: add TypeMap[V] #67161
- put on hold

rsc · 2024-06-12T20:59:26Z

2024-06-12 / @adonovan, @andybons, @cherrymui, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rolandshoemaker, @rsc

Discussions (not yet proposals)

gabyhelp feedback #67901
encoding/json/v2 #63397
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
gonew: templates for new modules #61669
metrics for the standard library #61638

Accepted

math/rand: make global Seed a no-op #67273
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
x/crypto/ssh: allow to change allowed authentication methods #66815
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

iter: SeqError type, Throw function #67924
- declined as infeasible
text/template: ability to resolve values from a dataset using templates #67766
- declined as infeasible

Likely Accept

crypto/x509: generate serial number for nil template SerialNumber #67675
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
hash/maphash: add func Comparable #54670
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
spec: allow range-over-func to omit iteration variables #65236
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
testing: add TB.Chdir #62516
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
x/sys: add unsafe mmap #56123
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
x/tools/go/analysis: identify test-only packages #65749
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

none

Active

cmd/go: enable GOCACHEPROG by default #64876
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: list deprecations and newer available major, minor versions #67420
- commented
cmd/gofmt: change -d to exit 1 if diffs exist #46289
- added to minutes
- commented
cmd/test2json: Allow Go Tests to Pass Metadata #43936
- discussion ongoing
compress/zstd: add new package #62513
- discussion ongoing
crypto/rand: add func Text #67057
- commented
crypto/tls: add Raw to ClientHelloInfo #32936
- added to minutes
crypto/tls: support kernel-provided TLS #44506
- commented
database/sql: allow driver to entirely override Scan #67546
- added to minutes
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
errors: add All and AllAs iterators #66455
- discussion ongoing
io/fs: add SymlinkFS interface #49580
- discussion ongoing
net/http: HTTP version selection API #67814
- added to minutes
net/http: HTTP/2 configuration API #67813
- added to minutes
net/http: customize limit on number of 1xx responses #65035
- added to minutes
net/http: support unencrypted HTTP/2 (h2c) #67816
- added to minutes
os: safer file open functions #67002
- discussion ongoing
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- waiting on implementation experience
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- discussion ongoing
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
testing: reconsider adding Context method to testing.T #36532
- added to minutes
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing
x/net/http2: add per-write timeouts (WriteByteTimeout) #61777
- added to minutes
x/net/http2: configurable server pings #67812
- added to minutes
x/net/http2: move frame operations to x/net/http2/http2frame #67819
- added to minutes
x/oauth2: add Token.ExpiresIn struct field #61417
- discussion ongoing
x/tools/go/ast/inspector: add Inspector.PreorderSeq and top-level func All #67795
- added to minutes
- commented

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- hold for Microsoft
x/tools/go/types/typeutil: add TypeMap[V] #67161
- put on hold

rsc · 2024-06-24T18:16:02Z

[We met last Thursday but I am only posting the minutes today. Apologies.]

2024-06-20 / @andybons, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rolandshoemaker, @rsc

Discussions (not yet proposals)

gabyhelp feedback #67901
encoding/json/v2 #63397
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
gonew: templates for new modules #61669
metrics for the standard library #61638

Accepted

crypto/x509: generate serial number for nil template SerialNumber #67675
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
hash/maphash: add func Comparable #54670
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
spec: allow range-over-func to omit iteration variables #65236
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
testing: add TB.Chdir #62516
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
x/sys: add unsafe mmap #56123
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
x/tools/go/analysis: identify test-only packages #65749
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

none

Likely Accept

cmd/go: list deprecations and newer available major, minor versions #67420
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
cmd/gofmt: change -d to exit 1 if diffs exist #46289
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

none

Active

cmd/go: enable GOCACHEPROG by default #64876
- discussion ongoing
cmd/test2json: Allow Go Tests to Pass Metadata #43936
- discussion ongoing
compress/zstd: add new package #62513
- discussion ongoing
crypto/rand: add func Text #67057
- commented
crypto/tls: support kernel-provided TLS #44506
- commented
database/sql: allow driver to entirely override Scan #67546
- commented
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
errors: add All and AllAs iterators #66455
- discussion ongoing
io/fs: add SymlinkFS interface #49580
- discussion ongoing
net/http: HTTP version selection API #67814
- commented
net/http: HTTP/2 configuration API #67813
- added to minutes
net/http: customize limit on number of 1xx responses #65035
- commented
net/http: support unencrypted HTTP/2 (h2c) #67816
- commented
os: safer file open functions #67002
- discussion ongoing
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- waiting on implementation experience
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- discussion ongoing
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
testing: reconsider adding Context method to testing.T #36532
- added to minutes
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing
x/net/http2: add per-write timeouts (WriteByteTimeout) #61777
- commented
x/net/http2: configurable server pings #67812
- commented
x/net/http2: move frame operations to x/net/http2/http2frame #67819
- commented
x/oauth2: add Token.ExpiresIn struct field #61417
- discussion ongoing
x/tools/go/ast/inspector: add Inspector.PreorderSeq and top-level func All #67795
- commented

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- hold for Microsoft
x/tools/go/types/typeutil: add TypeMap[V] #67161
- put on hold

rsc · 2024-06-27T16:33:32Z

2024-06-26 / @adonovan, @andybons, @aclements, @bradfitz, @cherrymui, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rolandshoemaker, @rsc

Discussions (not yet proposals)

gabyhelp feedback #67901
encoding/json/v2 #63397
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
gonew: templates for new modules #61669
metrics for the standard library #61638

Accepted

cmd/go: list deprecations and newer available major, minor versions #67420
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
cmd/gofmt: change -d to exit 1 if diffs exist #46289
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

none

Likely Accept

crypto/tls: add Extensions to ClientHelloInfo #32936
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
x/net/http2: add per-write timeouts (WriteByteTimeout) #61777
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
x/net/http2: configurable server pings #67812
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
x/tools/go/ast/inspector: add Inspector.PreorderSeq and top-level func All #67795
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

none

Active

cmd/go: enable GOCACHEPROG by default #64876
- discussion ongoing
cmd/test2json: Allow Go Tests to Pass Metadata #43936
- discussion ongoing
compress/zstd: add new package #62513
- discussion ongoing
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
errors: add All and AllAs iterators #66455
- discussion ongoing
hash/maphash: add func Comparable #54670
- back to active
- commented
io/fs: add SymlinkFS interface #49580
- discussion ongoing
net/http: customize limit on number of 1xx responses #65035
- discussion ongoing
net/http: support unencrypted HTTP/2 (h2c) #67816
- commented
os: safer file open functions #67002
- discussion ongoing
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- waiting on implementation experience
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- discussion ongoing
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
testing: reconsider adding Context method to testing.T #36532
- discussion ongoing
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing
x/oauth2: add Token.ExpiresIn struct field #61417
- discussion ongoing

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- hold for Microsoft
x/tools/go/types/typeutil: add TypeMap[V] #67161
- put on hold

rsc · 2024-07-11T02:38:13Z

Due to an unfortunate confluence of events, the next proposal review meeting will not be until July 25.
We missed July 3 due to the July 4th holiday in the US.
We missed July 10 due to GopherCon.
We will miss July 17 due to the scheduled Go quiet week.

Apologies for the relative silence.
We're in the release freeze, so at least it's not holding up landing any work.
Hope you are all having a relaxing summer.

rsc · 2024-07-25T10:06:00Z

2024-07-24 / @aclements, @bradfitz, @cherrymui, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rolandshoemaker, @rsc

Discussions (not yet proposals)

gabyhelp feedback #67901
x/oscar feedback #68490
encoding/json/v2 #63397
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
gonew: templates for new modules #61669
metrics for the standard library #61638

Accepted

crypto/tls: add Extensions to ClientHelloInfo #32936
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
x/net/http2: add per-write timeouts (WriteByteTimeout) #61777
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
x/net/http2: configurable server pings #67812
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
x/tools/go/ast/inspector: add Inspector.PreorderSeq and top-level func All #67795
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

io: add WriteAll function #67921
- declined as infeasible
testing: add (*testing.T).PassNow method #68128
- declined as infeasible

Likely Accept

crypto/rand: add func Text #67057
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/tls: support kernel-provided TLS #44506
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
database/sql: allow driver to entirely override Scan #67546
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
net/http: HTTP version selection API #67814
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
net/http: HTTP/2 configuration API #67813
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
x/net/http2: move frame operations to x/net/http2/http2frame #67819
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

none

Active

cmd/compile: spurious promotion of methods from embedded aliases of unnamed types #66540
- added to minutes
cmd/go: doc -http should start a pkgsite instance and open a browser #68106
- added to minutes
cmd/go: enable GOCACHEPROG by default #64876
- discussion ongoing
cmd/test2json: Allow Go Tests to Pass Metadata #43936
- discussion ongoing
cmd/vet: warn on 3-clause loops where an iterator variable contains a lock type when GoVersion>=1.22 #66387
- added to minutes
compress/zstd: add new package #62513
- commented
encoding/json: add omitzero option #45669
- added to minutes
errors: add All and AllAs iterators #66455
- commented
fmt: add iterator for format tokens #68279
- added to minutes
go/ast: add CommentGroup.Directives iterator #68021
- added to minutes
hash/maphash: add func Comparable #54670
- commented
io/fs: add SymlinkFS interface #49580
- commented
net/http: customize limit on number of 1xx responses #65035
- commented
os: safer file open functions #67002
- commented
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- commented
runtime: add AddCleanup and deprecate SetFinalizer #67535
- added to minutes
runtime: add RunOnMainThread to take control of the main thread #64777
- added to minutes
runtime: allow access to stopTheWorld/startTheWorld via go:linkname #68167
- added to minutes
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- discussion ongoing
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
testing: reconsider adding Context method to testing.T #36532
- commented
weak: new package providing weak pointers #67552
- added to minutes
x/crypto: add crypt(3) password hash algorithms #14274
- added to minutes
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing
x/net/html: add Node.All(), Node.ChildNodes(), Nodes.Parents() iterators #62113
- added to minutes
x/oauth2: add Token.ExpiresIn struct field #61417
- commented
x/sys/unix: add support for linux' TCP_CC_INFO #68232
- added to minutes
x/telemetry: expand the scope of Go Telemetry to include Delve #68384
- added to minutes

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- hold for Microsoft
x/tools/go/types/typeutil: add TypeMap[V] #67161
- put on hold

rsc · 2024-07-31T19:10:47Z

2024-07-31 / @aclements, @adonovan, @andybons, @bradfitz, @cherrymui, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rolandshoemaker, @rsc

Discussions (not yet proposals)

gabyhelp feedback #67901
x/oscar feedback #68490
encoding/json/v2 #63397
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
gonew: templates for new modules #61669
metrics for the standard library #61638

Accepted

crypto/rand: add func Text #67057
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto/tls: support kernel-provided TLS #44506
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
database/sql: allow driver to entirely override Scan #67546
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
net/http: HTTP version selection API #67814
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
net/http: HTTP/2 configuration API #67813
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
x/net/http2: move frame operations to x/net/http2/http2frame #67819
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

none

Likely Accept

hash/maphash: add func Comparable #54670
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
net/http: support unencrypted HTTP/2 (h2c) #67816
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

x/crypto: add crypt(3) password hash algorithms #14274
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳

Active

cmd/compile: spurious promotion of methods from embedded aliases of unnamed types #66540
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: doc -http should start a pkgsite instance and open a browser #68106
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: enable GOCACHEPROG by default #64876
- discussion ongoing
cmd/test2json: Allow Go Tests to Pass Metadata #43936
- discussion ongoing
cmd/vet: warn on 3-clause loops where an iterator variable contains a lock type when GoVersion>=1.22 #66387
- discussion ongoing
compress/zstd: add new package #62513
- commented
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- commented
encoding/json: add omitzero option #45669
- discussion ongoing
errors: add All and AllAs iterators #66455
- commented
fmt: add iterator for format tokens #68279
- commented
go/ast: add CommentGroup.Directives iterator #68021
- discussion ongoing
io/fs: add SymlinkFS interface #49580
- commented
net/http: customize limit on number of 1xx responses #65035
- commented
os: safer file open functions #67002
- commented
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- commented
runtime: add AddCleanup and deprecate SetFinalizer #67535
- commented
runtime: add RunOnMainThread to take control of the main thread #64777
- commented
runtime: allow access to stopTheWorld/startTheWorld via go:linkname #68167
- discussion ongoing
runtime: implement a DIT/DOIT mode #66450
- added to minutes
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- discussion ongoing
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
testing: reconsider adding Context method to testing.T #36532
- commented
weak: new package providing weak pointers #67552
- discussion ongoing
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing
x/net/html: add Node.All(), Node.ChildNodes(), Nodes.Parents() iterators #62113
- discussion ongoing
x/oauth2: add Token.ExpiresIn struct field #61417
- commented
x/sys/unix: add support for linux' TCP_CC_INFO #68232
- commented
x/telemetry: expand the scope of Go Telemetry to include Delve #68384
- discussion ongoing

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- hold for Microsoft
x/tools/go/types/typeutil: add TypeMap[V] #67161
- put on hold

rsc · 2024-08-07T23:14:53Z

2024-08-07 / @aclements, @adonovan, @bradfitz, @cherrymui, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rolandshoemaker, @rsc

Discussions (not yet proposals)

x/oscar feedback #68490
gabyhelp feedback #67901
encoding/json/v2 #63397
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
gonew: templates for new modules #61669
metrics for the standard library #61638

Accepted

hash/maphash: add func Comparable #54670
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
net/http: support unencrypted HTTP/2 (h2c) #67816
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

x/crypto: add crypt(3) password hash algorithms #14274
- no change in consensus; declined

Likely Accept

cmd/vet: warn on 3-clause loops where an iterator variable contains a lock type when GoVersion>=1.22 #66387
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
testing: reconsider adding Context method to testing.T #36532
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
x/oauth2: add Token.ExpiresIn struct field #61417
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

runtime: allow access to stopTheWorld/startTheWorld via go:linkname #68167
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳

Active

cmd/compile: spurious promotion of methods from embedded aliases of unnamed types #66540
- commented
cmd/go: doc -http should start a pkgsite instance and open a browser #68106
- commented
cmd/go: enable GOCACHEPROG by default #64876
- discussion ongoing
cmd/test2json: Allow Go Tests to Pass Metadata #43936
- discussion ongoing
compress/zstd: add new package #62513
- commented
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
encoding/json: add omitzero option #45669
- discussion ongoing
errors: add All and AllAs iterators #66455
- discussion ongoing
fmt: add iterator for format tokens #68279
- commented
go/ast: add CommentGroup.Directives iterator #68021
- discussion ongoing
io/fs: add SymlinkFS interface #49580
- commented
net/http: customize limit on number of 1xx responses #65035
- discussion ongoing
os: safer file open functions #67002
- discussion ongoing
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- commented
runtime: add AddCleanup and deprecate SetFinalizer #67535
- discussion ongoing
runtime: add RunOnMainThread to take control of the main thread #64777
- commented
runtime: implement a DIT/DOIT mode #66450
- commented
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- discussion ongoing
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
weak: new package providing weak pointers #67552
- discussion ongoing
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing
x/net/html: add Node.All(), Node.ChildNodes(), Nodes.Parents() iterators #62113
- discussion ongoing
x/sys/unix: add support for linux' TCP_CC_INFO #68232
- commented
x/telemetry: expand the scope of Go Telemetry to include Delve #68384
- discussion ongoing

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- hold for Microsoft
x/tools/go/types/typeutil: add TypeMap[V] #67161
- put on hold

rsc · 2024-08-14T18:24:36Z

[We will skip next week, 2024-08-21, due to vacations. We will be back 2024-08-28.]

2024-08-14 / @adonovan, @bradfitz, @cherrymui, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rsc

Discussions (not yet proposals)

gabyhelp feedback #67901
encoding/json/v2 #63397
x/oscar feedback #68490
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
gonew: templates for new modules #61669
metrics for the standard library #61638

Accepted

cmd/vet: warn on 3-clause loops where an iterator variable contains a lock type when GoVersion>=1.22 #66387
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
spec: document promotion of methods from embedded aliases of unnamed types #66540
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
testing: reconsider adding Context method to testing.T #36532
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
x/oauth2: add Token.ExpiresIn struct field #61417
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

runtime: allow access to stopTheWorld/startTheWorld via go:linkname #68167
- no change in consensus; declined

Likely Accept

runtime: add RunOnMainThread to take control of the main thread #64777
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

fmt: add iterator for format tokens #68279
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳

Active

cmd/compile: relax wasm32 function import signature type constraints #66984
- added to minutes
cmd/go: doc -http should start a pkgsite instance and open a browser #68106
- commented
cmd/go: enable GOCACHEPROG by default #64876
- discussion ongoing
cmd/test2json: Allow Go Tests to Pass Metadata #43936
- discussion ongoing
compress/zstd: add new package #62513
- commented
crypto/rsa: refuse to generate and/or use keys smaller than 1024 bits #68762
- added to minutes
crypto/tls: add ConnectionState.CurveID #67516
- added to minutes
crypto/tls: support server side Encrypted Client Hello #68500
- added to minutes
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
errors: add All and AllAs iterators #66455
- commented
go/ast: add CommentGroup.Directives iterator #68021
- discussion ongoing
io/fs: add SymlinkFS interface #49580
- commented
net/http: customize limit on number of 1xx responses #65035
- discussion ongoing
os: safer file open functions #67002
- discussion ongoing
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- discussion ongoing
runtime: implement a DIT/DOIT mode #66450
- discussion ongoing
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- discussion ongoing
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing
x/net/html: add Node.All(), Node.ChildNodes(), Nodes.Parents() iterators #62113
- commented
x/telemetry: expand the scope of Go Telemetry to include Delve #68384
- commented
x/tools/go/packages: add Dir and Target (and perhaps other) fields to Package struct #38445
- added to minutes

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- hold for Microsoft
x/tools/go/types/typeutil: add TypeMap[V] #67161
- put on hold

rsc · 2024-08-29T15:16:41Z

2024-08-28 / @adonovan, @andybons, @cherrymui, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rolandshoemaker, @rsc

Discussions (not yet proposals)

gabyhelp feedback #67901
encoding/json/v2 #63397
x/oscar feedback #68490
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
gonew: templates for new modules #61669
metrics for the standard library #61638

Accepted

runtime/mainthread: new package to manage main thread #64777
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

fmt: add iterator for format tokens #68279
- no change in consensus; declined

Likely Accept

cmd/go: doc -http should start a pkgsite instance and open a browser #68106
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/tls: add ConnectionState.CurveID #67516
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
encoding/json: add omitzero option #45669
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
x/sys/unix: add support for linux' TCP_CC_INFO #68232
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
x/telemetry: expand the scope of Go Telemetry to include Delve #68384
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

errors: add All and AllAs iterators #66455
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳

Active

all, x/build/cmd/relui: automate go directive maintenance in golang.org/x repositories #69095
- added to minutes
cmd/compile: relax wasm32 function import signature type constraints #66984
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: enable GOCACHEPROG by default #64876
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: unused (yet) dependencies added by go get should not be indirect #68593
- added to minutes
cmd/test2json: Allow Go Tests to Pass Metadata #43936
- discussion ongoing
compress/zstd: add new package #62513
- commented
crypto/tls: support server side Encrypted Client Hello #68500
- discussion ongoing
crypto/x509: support Inhibit Any-policy and Policy Constraints #68484
- added to minutes
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
go/ast: add CommentGroup.Directives iterator #68021
- discussion ongoing
io/fs: add SymlinkFS interface #49580
- discussion ongoing
net/http: customize limit on number of 1xx responses #65035
- commented
os: safer file open functions #67002
- commented
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- discussion ongoing
runtime: add a way to check if fd is used by go runtime #67639
- added to minutes
runtime: implement a DIT/DOIT mode #66450
- commented
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- commented
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
x/crypto/acme: Client.AcceptWithPayload to support device attestation extension #68674
- added to minutes
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing
x/net/html: add Node.All(), Node.ChildNodes(), Nodes.Parents() iterators #62113
- commented
x/tools/go/gcexportdata: Read to support only 2 Go releases + tip #68898
- added to minutes

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- hold for Microsoft
x/tools/go/types/typeutil: add TypeMap[V] #67161
- put on hold

rsc · 2024-09-04T18:51:00Z

2024-09-04 / @adonovan, @andybons, @bradfitz, @cherrymui, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rolandshoemaker, @rsc

Discussions (not yet proposals)

gabyhelp feedback #67901
encoding/json/v2 #63397
x/oscar feedback #68490
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
gonew: templates for new modules #61669
metrics for the standard library #61638

Accepted

cmd/go: doc -http should start a pkgsite instance and open a browser #68106
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto/tls: add ConnectionState.CurveID #67516
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
encoding/json: add omitzero option #45669
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
x/sys/unix: add support for linux' TCP_CC_INFO #68232
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
x/telemetry: expand the scope of Go Telemetry to include Delve #68384
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

cmd/go: consider making GOTELEMETRY=off settable #68960
- declined as infeasible
cmd/go: make GOTELEMETRY settable like other env vars #69113
- declined as infeasible
errors: add All and AllAs iterators #66455
- no change in consensus; declined

Likely Accept

compress/zstd: add new package #62513
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/rsa: refuse to generate and/or use keys smaller than 1024 bits #68762
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
runtime: add AddCleanup and deprecate SetFinalizer #67535
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
weak: new package providing weak pointers #67552
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
x/tools/go/packages: add Dir, Target, and ForTest fields to Package #38445
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

cmd/go: unused (yet) dependencies added by go get should not be indirect #68593
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳

Active

all, x/build/cmd/relui: automate go directive maintenance in golang.org/x repositories #69095
- discussion ongoing
cmd/compile: relax wasm32 function import signature type constraints #66984
- commented
cmd/go: add go mod verify -tag #68669
- added to minutes
cmd/go: enable GOCACHEPROG by default #64876
- discussion ongoing
cmd/link: add initial-memory and max-memory params #69018
- added to minutes
cmd/test2json: Allow Go Tests to Pass Metadata #43936
- discussion ongoing
crypto/rsa: allow hash.Hash for OAEP and MGF1 to be specified independently for encryption #65716
- added to minutes
crypto/subtle: add WithDataIndependentTiming #66450
- commented
crypto/tls: support server side Encrypted Client Hello #68500
- discussion ongoing
crypto/x509: support Inhibit Any-policy and Policy Constraints #68484
- discussion ongoing
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
go/ast: add CommentGroup.Directives iterator #68021
- discussion ongoing
go/format: simplify old directive comments #68061
- added to minutes
io/fs: add SymlinkFS interface #49580
- commented
log/slog: add `slog.DiscardHandler` #62005
- added to minutes
net/http: customize limit on number of 1xx responses #65035
- commented
os: safer file open functions #67002
- discussion ongoing
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- discussion ongoing
runtime: add a way to check if fd is used by go runtime #67639
- commented
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- discussion ongoing
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
x/crypto/acme: Client.AcceptWithPayload to support device attestation extension #68674
- commented
x/crypto: support OpenSSH variant of ChaCha20Poly1305 #57699
- added to minutes
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing
x/net/html: add Node.All(), Node.ChildNodes(), Nodes.Parents() iterators #62113
- commented
x/tools/go/gcexportdata: Read to support only 2 Go releases + tip #68898
- discussion ongoing

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- hold for Microsoft
x/tools/go/types/typeutil: add TypeMap[V] #67161
- put on hold

rsc · 2024-09-11T18:10:03Z

2024-09-11 / @adonovan, @andybons, @bradfitz, @cherrymui, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rolandshoemaker, @rsc

Discussions (not yet proposals)

gabyhelp feedback #67901
encoding/json/v2 #63397
x/oscar feedback #68490
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
gonew: templates for new modules #61669
metrics for the standard library #61638

Accepted

compress/zstd: add new package #62513
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto/rsa: refuse to generate and/or use keys smaller than 1024 bits #68762
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
runtime: add AddCleanup and deprecate SetFinalizer #67535
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
weak: new package providing weak pointers #67552
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
x/tools/go/packages: add Dir, Target, and ForTest fields to Package #38445
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

cmd/go: unused (yet) dependencies added by go get should not be indirect #68593
- no change in consensus; declined

Likely Accept

all, x/build/cmd/relui: automate go directive maintenance in golang.org/x repositories #69095
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
cmd/compile: relax wasm/wasm32 function import signature type constraints #66984
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/subtle: add WithDataIndependentTiming #66450
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/tls: support server side Encrypted Client Hello #68500
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
x/tools/cmd/gorename: tag and delete it #69360
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

go/format: simplify old directive comments #68061
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
runtime: add a way to check if fd is used by go runtime #67639
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳
x/crypto/ocsp: support request and response extensions #20001
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳

Active

cmd/go: add go mod verify -tag #68669
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: change go test to FAIL if `-run` is specified but no tests match #64500
- added to minutes
cmd/go: enable GOCACHEPROG by default #64876
- discussion ongoing
cmd/link: add wasminitmem and wasmmaxmem params #69018
- commented
cmd/test2json: Allow Go Tests to Pass Metadata #43936
- discussion ongoing
cmd/vet: warn about structs marked json omitempty #51261
- added to minutes
crypto/rsa: allow hash.Hash for OAEP and MGF1 to be specified independently for encryption #65716
- commented
crypto/x509: support Inhibit Any-policy and Policy Constraints #68484
- commented
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
go/ast: add CommentGroup.Directives iterator #68021
- discussion ongoing
io/fs: add SymlinkFS interface #49580
- commented
log/slog: add `slog.DiscardHandler` #62005
- commented
net/http: customize limit on number of 1xx responses #65035
- commented
os: safer file open functions #67002
- discussion ongoing
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- discussion ongoing
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- discussion ongoing
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
x/crypto/acme: Client.AcceptWithPayload to support device attestation extension #68674
- commented
x/crypto: support OpenSSH variant of ChaCha20Poly1305 #57699
- commented
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing
x/net/html: add Node methods Ancestors, Children, Descendants #62113
- commented
x/tools/go/gcexportdata: Read to support only 2 Go releases + tip #68898
- discussion ongoing
x/tools/go/ssa/ssautil: Reachable: conservative approximation to reachable functions, runtime types #69291
- added to minutes

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- hold for Microsoft
x/tools/go/types/typeutil: add TypeMap[V] #67161
- put on hold

aclements · 2024-09-18T23:09:14Z

2024-09-18 / @aclements, @adonovan, @andybons, @bradfitz, @cherrymui, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rolandshoemaker

Discussions (not yet proposals)

gabyhelp feedback #67901
encoding/json/v2 #63397
x/oscar feedback #68490
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
gonew: templates for new modules #61669
metrics for the standard library #61638

Accepted

all, x/build/cmd/relui: automate go directive maintenance in golang.org/x repositories #69095
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto/subtle: add WithDataIndependentTiming #66450
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto/tls: support server side Encrypted Client Hello #68500
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
x/tools/cmd/gorename: tag and delete it #69360
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

go/format: simplify old directive comments #68061
- no change in consensus; declined
runtime: add a way to check if fd is used by go runtime #67639
- no change in consensus; declined
x/crypto/ocsp: support request and response extensions #20001
- no change in consensus; declined
x/tools/go/types/typeutil: add TypeMap[V] #67161
- proposal retracted by author; declined

Likely Accept

cmd/compile: relax wasm/wasm32 function import signature type constraints #66984
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

x/crypto: support OpenSSH variant of ChaCha20Poly1305 #57699
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳

Active

cmd/go: add go mod verify -tag #68669
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: change go test to FAIL if `-run` is specified but no tests match #64500
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: enable GOCACHEPROG by default #64876
- commented
cmd/link: add wasminitmem and wasmmaxmem params #69018
- commented
cmd/test2json: Allow Go Tests to Pass Metadata #43936
- discussion ongoing
cmd/vet: warn about structs marked json omitempty #51261
- discussion ongoing
crypto/rsa: allow hash.Hash for OAEP and MGF1 to be specified independently for encryption #65716
- commented
crypto/x509: support Inhibit Any-policy and Policy Constraints #68484
- discussion ongoing
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
go/ast: add CommentGroup.Directives iterator #68021
- commented
io/fs: add SymlinkFS interface #49580
- discussion ongoing
log/slog: add `slog.DiscardHandler` #62005
- discussion ongoing
net/http: customize limit on number of 1xx responses #65035
- commented
os: safer file open functions #67002
- discussion ongoing
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- commented
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- discussion ongoing
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- commented
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
x/crypto/acme: Client.AcceptWithPayload to support device attestation extension #68674
- discussion ongoing
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing
x/net/html: add Node methods Ancestors, Children, Descendants #62113
- discussion ongoing
x/tools/go/gcexportdata: Read to support only 2 Go releases + tip #68898
- discussion ongoing
x/tools/go/ssa/ssautil: Reachable: conservative approximation to reachable functions, runtime types #69291
- discussion ongoing

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- hold for Microsoft

aclements · 2024-09-25T18:58:07Z

2024-09-25 / @aclements, @adonovan, @andybons, @bradfitz, @griesemer, @rolandshoemaker

Discussions (not yet proposals)

gabyhelp feedback #67901
encoding/json/v2 #63397
x/oscar feedback #68490
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
gonew: templates for new modules #61669
metrics for the standard library #61638

Accepted

none

Declined

x/crypto: support OpenSSH variant of ChaCha20Poly1305 #57699
- no change in consensus; declined

Likely Accept

cmd/compile: relax wasm/wasm32 function import signature type constraints #66984
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

none

Active

cmd/go: add go mod verify -tag #68669
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: change go test to FAIL if `-run` is specified but no tests match #64500
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: enable GOCACHEPROG by default #64876
- discussion ongoing
cmd/link: add wasminitmem and wasmmaxmem params #69018
- discussion ongoing
cmd/test2json: Allow Go Tests to Pass Metadata #43936
- discussion ongoing
cmd/vet: warn about structs marked json omitempty #51261
- discussion ongoing
crypto/rsa: allow hash.Hash for OAEP and MGF1 to be specified independently for encryption #65716
- discussion ongoing
crypto/x509: support Inhibit Any-policy and Policy Constraints #68484
- discussion ongoing
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
go/ast: add CommentGroup.Directives iterator #68021
- commented
io/fs: add SymlinkFS interface #49580
- commented
log/slog: add `slog.DiscardHandler` #62005
- discussion ongoing
net/http: customize limit on number of 1xx responses #65035
- commented
os: safer file open functions #67002
- commented
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- commented
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- discussion ongoing
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- discussion ongoing
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
x/crypto/acme: Client.AcceptWithPayload to support device attestation extension #68674
- commented
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing
x/net/html: add Node methods Ancestors, Children, Descendants #62113
- commented
x/tools/go/gcexportdata: Read to support only 2 Go releases + tip #68898
- commented
x/tools/go/ssa/ssautil: Reachable: conservative approximation to reachable functions, runtime types #69291
- commented

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- hold for Microsoft

aclements · 2024-10-04T14:56:23Z

2024-10-02 / @aclements, @adonovan, @bradfitz, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rolandshoemaker

Discussions (not yet proposals)

gabyhelp feedback #67901
encoding/json/v2 #63397
x/oscar feedback #68490
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
gonew: templates for new modules #61669
metrics for the standard library #61638

Accepted

none

Declined

none

Likely Accept

cmd/compile: relax wasm/wasm32 function import signature type constraints #66984
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
net/http: customize limit on number of 1xx responses #65035
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

cmd/go: change go test to FAIL if `-run` is specified but no tests match #64500
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳

Active

cmd/go: add go mod verify -tag #68669
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: enable GOCACHEPROG by default #64876
- commented
cmd/link: add wasminitmem and wasmmaxmem params #69018
- commented
cmd/test2json: Allow Go Tests to Pass Metadata #43936
- discussion ongoing
cmd/vet: warn about structs marked json omitempty #51261
- commented
crypto/rsa: allow hash.Hash for OAEP and MGF1 to be specified independently for encryption #65716
- discussion ongoing
crypto/x509: support Inhibit Any-policy and Policy Constraints #68484
- discussion ongoing
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
go/ast: add ParseDirective #68021
- commented
io/fs: add ReadLinkFS interface #49580
- commented
log/slog: add `slog.DiscardHandler` #62005
- commented
math: add Mean, Median, Mode, Variance, and StdDev #69264
- added to minutes
os: safer file open functions #67002
- commented
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- discussion ongoing
testing/synctest: experimental package for testing concurrent code #69687
- added to minutes
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- discussion ongoing
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
x/crypto/acme: Client.AcceptWithPayload to support device attestation extension #68674
- commented
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing
x/net/html: add Node methods Ancestors, ChildNodes, Descendants #62113
- commented
x/tools/go/gcexportdata: Read to support only 2 Go releases + tip #68898
- commented
x/tools/go/ssa/ssautil: Reachable: conservative approximation to reachable functions, runtime types #69291
- commented

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- hold for Microsoft

aclements · 2024-10-23T19:49:18Z

And we're back from a few weeks without proposal review.

aclements · 2024-10-23T19:49:42Z

2024-10-23 / @aclements, @adonovan, @andybons, @cherrymui, @griesemer, @rolandshoemaker

Discussions (not yet proposals)

gabyhelp feedback #67901
encoding/json/v2 #63397
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
metrics for the standard library #61638
x/oscar feedback #68490
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
gonew: templates for new modules #61669

Accepted

cmd/compile: relax wasm/wasm32 function import signature type constraints #66984
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
net/http: customize limit on number of 1xx responses #65035
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

cmd/go: change go test to FAIL if `-run` is specified but no tests match #64500
- no change in consensus; declined

Likely Accept

cmd/go: enable GOCACHEPROG by default #64876
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
io/fs: add ReadLinkFS interface #49580
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
log/slog: add `slog.DiscardHandler` #62005
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
x/crypto/acme: Client.AcceptWithPayload to support device attestation extension #68674
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
x/net/html: add Node methods Ancestors, ChildNodes, Descendants #62113
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
x/tools/go/gcexportdata: Read to support only 2 Go releases + tip #68898
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

none

Active

all: end support for macOS 11 in Go 1.25 #69839
- added to minutes
cmd/go: add go mod verify -tag #68669
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: cache link output binaries in the build cache #69290
- added to minutes
cmd/link: add wasminitmem and wasmmaxmem params #69018
- commented
cmd/test2json: Allow Go Tests to Pass Metadata #43936
- commented
cmd/vet: warn about structs marked json omitempty #51261
- commented
crypto/cipher: add NewGCMWithRandomNonce #69981
- added to minutes
crypto/cipher: deprecate NewOFB, NewCFBDecrypter and NewCFBEncrypter #69445
- added to minutes
crypto/hkdf: add package #61477
- added to minutes
crypto/pbkdf2: add package #69488
- added to minutes
crypto/rsa: allow hash.Hash for OAEP and MGF1 to be specified independently for encryption #65716
- discussion ongoing
crypto/sha3: import from x/crypto #69982
- added to minutes
crypto/tls: SecP256r1MLKEM768 and X25519MLKEM768 #69985
- added to minutes
crypto/tls: automatic CurvePreferences ordering #69393
- added to minutes
crypto/x509: support Inhibit Any-policy and Policy Constraints #68484
- discussion ongoing
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
encoding/xml: add flag for stricter XML char parsing #69503
- added to minutes
go/types: add Hash function #69420
- added to minutes
hash: add XOF interface #69518
- added to minutes
math: add Mean, Median, Mode, Variance, and StdDev #69264
- discussion ongoing
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- discussion ongoing
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- discussion ongoing
testing/synctest: experimental package for testing concurrent code #69687
- discussion ongoing
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- commented
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing
x/tools/go/ssa/ssautil: Reachable: conservative approximation to reachable functions, runtime types #69291
- discussion ongoing

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation

aclements · 2024-10-30T20:18:24Z

2024-10-30 / @aclements, @adonovan, @bradfitz, @cherrymui, @griesemer, @rolandshoemaker

Discussions (not yet proposals)

gabyhelp feedback #67901
encoding/json/v2 #63397
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
metrics for the standard library #61638
x/oscar feedback #68490
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
gonew: templates for new modules #61669

Accepted

cmd/go: enable GOCACHEPROG by default #64876
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
io/fs: add ReadLinkFS interface #49580
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
log/slog: add `slog.DiscardHandler` #62005
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
x/crypto/acme: Client.AcceptWithPayload to support device attestation extension #68674
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
x/net/html: add Node methods Ancestors, ChildNodes, Descendants #62113
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
x/tools/go/gcexportdata: Read to support only 2 Go releases + tip #68898
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

none

Likely Accept

go/ast: add ParseDirective #68021
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
os: safer file open functions #67002
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

none

Active

all: end support for macOS 11 in Go 1.25 #69839
- commented
cmd/go: add go mod verify -tag #68669
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: cache link output binaries in the build cache #69290
- commented
cmd/link: add wasminitmem and wasmmaxmem params #69018
- commented
cmd/test2json: Allow Go Tests to Pass Metadata #43936
- commented
cmd/vet: warn about structs marked json omitempty #51261
- commented
crypto/cipher: add NewGCMWithRandomNonce #69981
- commented
crypto/cipher: deprecate NewOFB, NewCFBDecrypter and NewCFBEncrypter #69445
- discussion ongoing
crypto/hkdf: add package #61477
- discussion ongoing
crypto/pbkdf2: add package #69488
- discussion ongoing
crypto/rsa: allow hash.Hash for OAEP and MGF1 to be specified independently for encryption #65716
- discussion ongoing
crypto/sha3: import from x/crypto #69982
- discussion ongoing
crypto/tls: SecP256r1MLKEM768 and X25519MLKEM768 #69985
- discussion ongoing
crypto/tls: automatic CurvePreferences ordering #69393
- discussion ongoing
crypto/x509: support Inhibit Any-policy and Policy Constraints #68484
- commented
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
encoding/xml: add flag for stricter XML char parsing #69503
- discussion ongoing
go/types: add Hash function #69420
- discussion ongoing
hash: add XOF interface #69518
- discussion ongoing
math: add Mean, Median, Mode, Variance, and StdDev #69264
- discussion ongoing
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- discussion ongoing
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- commented
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- discussion ongoing
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing
x/tools/go/ssa/ssautil: Reachable: conservative approximation to reachable functions, runtime types #69291
- commented

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
testing/synctest: experimental package for testing concurrent code #69687
- hold for implementation

aclements · 2024-11-06T19:33:52Z

2024-11-06 / @aclements, @adonovan, @bradfitz, @cherrymui, @ianlancetaylor

Discussions (not yet proposals)

encoding/json/v2 #63397
gabyhelp feedback #67901
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
metrics for the standard library #61638
x/oscar feedback #68490
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
gonew: templates for new modules #61669

Accepted

go/ast: add ParseDirective #68021
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
os: safer file open functions #67002
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

none

Likely Accept

all: end support for macOS 11 in Go 1.25 #69839
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/cipher: add NewGCMWithRandomNonce #69981
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/sha3: import from x/crypto #69982
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/tls: automatic CurvePreferences ordering #69393
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
x/tools/go/ssa/ssautil: Reachable: conservative approximation to reachable functions, runtime types #69291
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

none

Active

cmd/go: add fips140 module selection mechanism #70200
- added to minutes
cmd/go: add go mod verify -tag #68669
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: cache link output binaries in the build cache #69290
- discussion ongoing
cmd/link: add wasminitmem and wasmmaxmem params #69018
- discussion ongoing
cmd/test2json: Allow Go Tests to Pass Metadata #43936
- discussion ongoing
cmd/vet: warn about structs marked json omitempty #51261
- discussion ongoing
crypto/cipher: deprecate NewOFB, NewCFBDecrypter and NewCFBEncrypter #69445
- discussion ongoing
crypto/hkdf: add package #61477
- discussion ongoing
crypto/mlkem: new package #70122
- added to minutes
crypto/pbkdf2: add package #69488
- commented
crypto/rsa: allow hash.Hash for OAEP and MGF1 to be specified independently for encryption #65716
- discussion ongoing
crypto/tls: SecP256r1MLKEM768 and X25519MLKEM768 #69985
- commented
crypto/x509: support Inhibit Any-policy and Policy Constraints #68484
- discussion ongoing
crypto: mechanism to enable FIPS mode #70123
- added to minutes
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
encoding/xml: add flag for stricter XML char parsing #69503
- discussion ongoing
go/types: add Hash function #69420
- commented
hash: add Clone and CloneXOF #69521
- added to minutes
hash: add XOF interface #69518
- commented
math: add Mean, Median, Mode, Variance, and StdDev #69264
- discussion ongoing
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- discussion ongoing
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- discussion ongoing
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- discussion ongoing
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
testing/synctest: experimental package for testing concurrent code #69687
- hold for implementation

aclements · 2024-11-13T19:45:31Z

2024-11-13 / @aclements, @andybons, @cherrymui, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rolandshoemaker

Discussions (not yet proposals)

memory regions #70257
encoding/json/v2 #63397
gabyhelp feedback #67901
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
metrics for the standard library #61638
x/oscar feedback #68490
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
gonew: templates for new modules #61669

Accepted

all: end support for macOS 11 in Go 1.25 #69839
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto/cipher: add NewGCMWithRandomNonce #69981
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto/sha3: import from x/crypto #69982
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto/tls: automatic CurvePreferences ordering #69393
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
x/tools/go/ssa/ssautil: Reachable: conservative approximation to reachable functions, runtime types #69291
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

none

Likely Accept

cmd/go: cache link output binaries in the build cache #69290
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/hkdf: add package #61477
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/pbkdf2: add package #69488
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/tls: SecP256r1MLKEM768 and X25519MLKEM768 #69985
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
crypto: mechanism to enable FIPS mode #70123
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
testing/synctest: experimental package for testing concurrent code #69687
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

cmd/link: add wasminitmem and wasmmaxmem params #69018
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳

Active

cmd/go: add go mod verify -tag #68669
- commented
cmd/test2json: Allow Go Tests to Pass Metadata #43936
- commented
cmd/vet: warn about structs marked json omitempty #51261
- discussion ongoing
crypto/cipher: deprecate NewOFB, NewCFBDecrypter and NewCFBEncrypter #69445
- discussion ongoing
crypto/mlkem: new package #70122
- discussion ongoing
crypto/rsa: allow hash.Hash for OAEP and MGF1 to be specified independently for encryption #65716
- discussion ongoing
crypto/x509: support Inhibit Any-policy and Policy Constraints #68484
- discussion ongoing
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
encoding/xml: add flag for stricter XML char parsing #69503
- discussion ongoing
go/types: add Hash function #69420
- discussion ongoing
hash: add Clone and CloneXOF #69521
- discussion ongoing
hash: add XOF interface #69518
- discussion ongoing
math: add Mean, Median, Mode, Variance, and StdDev #69264
- discussion ongoing
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
remove notion of core types from the language spec. #70128
- added to minutes
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- discussion ongoing
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- discussion ongoing
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- hold for experience

aclements · 2024-11-21T04:13:22Z

2024-11-20 / @aclements, @adonovan, @bradfitz, @cherrymui, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rolandshoemaker

Discussions (not yet proposals)

encoding/json/v2 #63397
memory regions #70257
gabyhelp feedback #67901
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
metrics for the standard library #61638
x/oscar feedback #68490
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
gonew: templates for new modules #61669

Accepted

cmd/go: cache link output binaries in the build cache #69290
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto/hkdf: add package #61477
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto/pbkdf2: add package #69488
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto/tls: SecP256r1MLKEM768 and X25519MLKEM768 #69985
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto: mechanism to enable FIPS mode #70123
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
testing/synctest: experimental package for testing concurrent code #69687
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

cmd/link: add wasminitmem and wasmmaxmem params #69018
- no change in consensus; declined

Likely Accept

cmd/go: add fips140 module selection mechanism #70200
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/cipher: deprecate NewOFB, NewCFBDecrypter and NewCFBEncrypter #69445
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳
crypto/mlkem: new package #70122
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

none

Active

cmd/go: add go mod verify -tag #68669
- commented
crypto/rsa: allow hash.Hash for OAEP and MGF1 to be specified independently for encryption #65716
- discussion ongoing
crypto/x509: support Inhibit Any-policy and Policy Constraints #68484
- discussion ongoing
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
encoding/xml: add flag for stricter XML char parsing #69503
- commented
hash: add Clone and CloneXOF #69521
- discussion ongoing
hash: add XOF interface #69518
- discussion ongoing
math: add Mean, Median, Mode, Variance, and StdDev #69264
- discussion ongoing
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
remove notion of core types from the language spec. #70128
- added to minutes
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- discussion ongoing
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- discussion ongoing
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
testing: structured output for test attributes #43936
- commented
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
go/types: add Hash function #69420
- put on hold
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- hold for experience

aclements · 2024-11-27T22:52:00Z

2024-11-27 / @aclements, @adonovan, @cherrymui, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rolandshoemaker

Discussions (not yet proposals)

gabyhelp feedback #67901
encoding/json/v2 #63397
memory regions #70257
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
metrics for the standard library #61638
x/oscar feedback #68490
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
gonew: templates for new modules #61669

Accepted

cmd/go: add fips140 module selection mechanism #70200
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto/cipher: deprecate NewOFB, NewCFBDecrypter and NewCFBEncrypter #69445
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
crypto/mlkem: new package #70122
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

none

Likely Accept

cmd/vet: warn about structs marked json omitempty #51261
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

none

Active

cmd/go: add go mod verify -tag #68669
- discussion ongoing
crypto/rsa: allow hash.Hash for OAEP and MGF1 to be specified independently for encryption #65716
- discussion ongoing
crypto/x509: support Inhibit Any-policy and Policy Constraints #68484
- discussion ongoing
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
encoding/xml: add flag for stricter XML char parsing #69503
- discussion ongoing
hash: add Clone and CloneXOF #69521
- discussion ongoing
hash: add XOF interface #69518
- commented
math: add Mean, Median, Mode, Variance, and StdDev #69264
- commented
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
remove notion of core types from the language spec. #70128
- commented
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- discussion ongoing
runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- discussion ongoing
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
testing: structured output for test attributes #43936
- commented
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
go/types: add Hash function #69420
- put on hold
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- hold for experience

rsc · 2024-12-04T23:47:07Z

2024-12-04 / @adonovan, @cherrymui, @rolandshoemaker, @rsc

Discussions (not yet proposals)

memory regions #70257
encoding/json/v2 #63397
gabyhelp feedback #67901
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
metrics for the standard library #61638
x/oscar feedback #68490
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
gonew: templates for new modules #61669

Accepted

cmd/vet: warn about structs marked json omitempty #51261
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉
testing: panic in AllocsPerRun during parallel test #70464
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

none

Likely Accept

crypto/x509: support Inhibit Any-policy and Policy Constraints #68484
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- likely decline; last call for comments ⏳

Active

cmd/go: `-json` flag for `go version -m` #69712
- added to minutes
cmd/go: add go mod verify -tag #68669
- discussion ongoing
cmd/vet: add check for sync.WaitGroup abuse #18022
- added to minutes
container/unordered: a generic hash table with custom hash function and equivalence relation #69559
- added to minutes
crypto/rsa: allow hash.Hash for OAEP and MGF1 to be specified independently for encryption #65716
- commented
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
encoding/xml: add flag for stricter XML char parsing #69503
- discussion ongoing
go/types: add Info.ImplicitConversions mapping #70638
- added to minutes
go/types: add Var.Kind method and enum #70250
- added to minutes
hash: add Clone and CloneXOF #69521
- commented
hash: add XOF interface #69518
- commented
hash: standardize the hash function #70471
- added to minutes
math: add Mean, Median, Mode, Variance, and StdDev #69264
- commented
os: access to ELF auxiliary vector #67839
- added to minutes
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
runtime/mainthread: add mainthread.Do for mediating access to the main thread #70089
- added to minutes
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- commented
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
testing: structured output for test attributes #43936
- discussion ongoing
x/crypto/ssh: add ServerConfig.PreAuthConnCallback, ServerPreAuthConn (banner) interface #68688
- added to minutes
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing
x/tools/go/gcexportdata: drop experimental bundle API #69573
- added to minutes
x/tools/go/{packages/packagestest,expect}: deprecate, tag, and delete #70229
- added to minutes
x/tools: tag and delete refactor/rename, refactor/importgraph, go/buildutil, cmd/gomvpkg #69538
- added to minutes

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
go/types: add Hash function #69420
- put on hold
spec: remove notion of core types #70128
- hold for implementation
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- hold for experience

aclements · 2024-12-11T20:51:23Z

2024-12-11 / @aclements, @adonovan, @bradfitz, @cherrymui, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor

Discussions (not yet proposals)

memory regions #70257
encoding/json/v2 #63397
gabyhelp feedback #67901
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
metrics for the standard library #61638
x/oscar feedback #68490
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
gonew: templates for new modules #61669

Accepted

crypto/x509: support Inhibit Any-policy and Policy Constraints #68484
- no change in consensus; accepted 🎉

Declined

runtime: don't enable process-wide long path support on Windows #66560
- no change in consensus; declined

Likely Accept

none

Likely Decline

none

Active

cmd/go: `-json` flag for `go version -m` #69712
- commented
cmd/go: add go mod verify -tag #68669
- commented
cmd/vet: add check for sync.WaitGroup abuse #18022
- commented
container/unordered: a generic hash table with custom hash function and equivalence relation #69559
- discussion ongoing
crypto/rsa: allow hash.Hash for OAEP and MGF1 to be specified independently for encryption #65716
- discussion ongoing
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
encoding/xml: add flag for stricter XML char parsing #69503
- commented
go/types: add Info.ImplicitConversions mapping #70638
- commented
go/types: add Var.Kind method and enum #70250
- discussion ongoing
hash: add Clone and CloneXOF #69521
- commented
hash: add XOF interface #69518
- commented
hash: standardize the hash function #70471
- commented
math: add Mean, Median, Mode, Variance, and StdDev #69264
- commented
os: access to ELF auxiliary vector #67839
- commented
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- commented
runtime/mainthread: add mainthread.Do for mediating access to the main thread #70089
- discussion ongoing
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- commented
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
testing: structured output for test attributes #43936
- commented
x/crypto/ssh: add ServerConfig.PreAuthConnCallback, ServerPreAuthConn (banner) interface #68688
- discussion ongoing
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing
x/tools/go/gcexportdata: drop experimental bundle API #69573
- discussion ongoing
x/tools/go/{packages/packagestest,expect}: deprecate, tag, and delete #70229
- discussion ongoing
x/tools: tag and delete refactor/rename, refactor/importgraph, go/buildutil, cmd/gomvpkg #69538
- discussion ongoing

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
go/types: add Hash function #69420
- put on hold
spec: remove notion of core types #70128
- hold for implementation
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- hold for experience

aclements · 2024-12-19T21:10:10Z

2024-12-18 / @aclements, @adonovan, @bradfitz, @cherrymui, @griesemer, @ianlancetaylor, @rolandshoemaker

Discussions (not yet proposals)

gabyhelp feedback #67901
memory regions #70257
encoding/json/v2 #63397
codereview: should the Go project stop importing GitHub PRs? #61182
metrics for the standard library #61638
x/oscar feedback #68490
net/http: move HTTP/2 into the standard library #60746
gonew: templates for new modules #61669

Accepted

none

Declined

none

Likely Accept

x/tools/go/gcexportdata: drop experimental bundle API #69573
- likely accept; last call for comments ⏳

Likely Decline

none

Active

cmd/go: `-json` flag for `go version -m` #69712
- discussion ongoing
cmd/go: add go mod verify -tag #68669
- discussion ongoing
cmd/vet: add check for sync.WaitGroup abuse #18022
- discussion ongoing
container/unordered: a generic hash table with custom hash function and equivalence relation #69559
- discussion ongoing
crypto/rsa: allow hash.Hash for OAEP and MGF1 to be specified independently for encryption #65716
- commented
debug/bisect: publish x/tools/internal/bisect #67140
- discussion ongoing
encoding/xml: add flag for stricter XML char parsing #69503
- discussion ongoing
go/types: add Info.ImplicitConversions mapping #70638
- discussion ongoing
go/types: add Var.Kind method and enum #70250
- discussion ongoing
hash: add Clone and CloneXOF #69521
- discussion ongoing
hash: add XOF interface #69518
- commented
hash: standardize the hash function #70471
- commented
math: add Mean, Median, Mode, Variance, and StdDev #69264
- discussion ongoing
os: access to ELF auxiliary vector #67839
- discussion ongoing
regexp: add iterator forms of matching methods #61902
- discussion ongoing
runtime/mainthread: add mainthread.Do for mediating access to the main thread #70089
- commented
runtime/trace: flight recording #63185
- commented
testing: Add T.Output() etc #59928
- discussion ongoing
testing: structured output for test attributes #43936
- discussion ongoing
x/crypto/ssh: add ServerConfig.PreAuthConnCallback, ServerPreAuthConn (banner) interface #68688
- commented
x/exp/xiter: new package with iterator adapters #61898
- discussion ongoing
x/tools/go/{packages/packagestest,expect}: deprecate, tag, and delete #70229
- discussion ongoing
x/tools: tag and delete refactor/rename, refactor/importgraph, go/buildutil, cmd/gomvpkg #69538
- commented

Hold

cmd/fix: automate migrations for simple deprecations #32816
- hold for implementation
go/types: add Hash function #69420
- put on hold
spec: remove notion of core types #70128
- hold for implementation
testing/synctest: new package for testing concurrent code #67434
- hold for experience

golang locked and limited conversation to collaborators Aug 6, 2019

rsc changed the title ~~placeholder~~ proposal: review meeting minutes Aug 6, 2019

gopherbot added this to the Proposal milestone Aug 6, 2019

gopherbot added the Proposal label Aug 6, 2019

proposal: review meeting minutes #33502

proposal: review meeting minutes #33502

Comments

rsc commented Aug 6, 2019 • edited Loading

rsc commented Aug 6, 2019 • edited Loading

andybons commented Aug 13, 2019

andybons commented Aug 20, 2019 • edited Loading

andybons commented Aug 27, 2019

griesemer commented Sep 3, 2019

andybons commented Sep 12, 2019

andybons commented Sep 18, 2019 • edited by rsc Loading

andybons commented Sep 25, 2019 • edited by rsc Loading

andybons commented Oct 2, 2019 • edited by rsc Loading

andybons commented Oct 9, 2019

Proposals

Issues with NeedsDecision label

andybons commented Oct 16, 2019 • edited Loading

griesemer commented Oct 23, 2019

andybons commented Oct 30, 2019

Proposals

Issues with NeedsDecision label

andybons commented Nov 6, 2019

andybons commented Nov 13, 2019

andybons commented Nov 20, 2019

rsc commented Nov 27, 2019

andybons commented Dec 4, 2019 • edited by FiloSottile Loading

rsc commented Dec 11, 2019 • edited Loading

rsc commented Jan 8, 2020

rsc commented Jan 15, 2020

rsc commented Jan 22, 2020

rsc commented Feb 5, 2020

rsc commented Feb 12, 2020 • edited Loading

rsc commented Feb 26, 2020 • edited Loading

rsc commented Mar 4, 2020

rsc commented May 1, 2024

rsc commented May 8, 2024

rsc commented May 15, 2024

rsc commented May 23, 2024

rsc commented May 30, 2024 • edited Loading

rsc commented Jun 5, 2024 • edited Loading

rsc commented Jun 12, 2024

rsc commented Jun 24, 2024

rsc commented Jun 27, 2024

rsc commented Jul 11, 2024

rsc commented Jul 25, 2024 • edited by seankhliao Loading

rsc commented Jul 31, 2024

rsc commented Aug 7, 2024

rsc commented Aug 14, 2024

rsc commented Aug 29, 2024

rsc commented Sep 4, 2024

rsc commented Sep 11, 2024

aclements commented Sep 18, 2024

aclements commented Sep 25, 2024

aclements commented Oct 4, 2024

aclements commented Oct 23, 2024

aclements commented Oct 23, 2024

aclements commented Oct 30, 2024

aclements commented Nov 6, 2024

aclements commented Nov 13, 2024

aclements commented Nov 21, 2024

aclements commented Nov 27, 2024

rsc commented Dec 4, 2024

aclements commented Dec 11, 2024

aclements commented Dec 19, 2024

rsc commented Aug 6, 2019 •

edited

Loading

rsc commented Aug 6, 2019 •

edited

Loading

andybons commented Aug 20, 2019 •

edited

Loading

andybons commented Sep 18, 2019 •

edited by rsc

Loading

andybons commented Sep 25, 2019 •

edited by rsc

Loading

andybons commented Oct 2, 2019 •

edited by rsc

Loading

andybons commented Oct 16, 2019 •

edited

Loading

andybons commented Dec 4, 2019 •

edited by FiloSottile

Loading

rsc commented Dec 11, 2019 •

edited

Loading

rsc commented Feb 12, 2020 •

edited

Loading

rsc commented Feb 26, 2020 •

edited

Loading

rsc commented May 30, 2024 •

edited

Loading

rsc commented Jun 5, 2024 •

edited

Loading

rsc commented Jul 25, 2024 •

edited by seankhliao

Loading