diff --git a/pug/pug.py b/pug/pug.py
index 482ebce..e8642c2 100644
--- a/pug/pug.py
+++ b/pug/pug.py
@@ -786,24 +786,27 @@ async def move(
             Player(discord=player.id) for player in red_players + blu_players
         ]
         # Check if game was already added to searcher
-        genned: bool = True
         last_players: list[PugPlayer]
-        timestamp: int
+        old_timestamp: int
+        player_matches: int = 0
         try:
-            last_players, timestamp = await chosen_category.get_last_players(
+            last_players, old_timestamp = await chosen_category.get_last_players(
                 interaction.guild.id
             )
         except LookupError:
             last_players = []
-            timestamp = round(time.time()) - 7200
-        print(last_players)
+
         for player in last_players:
-            if player.discord not in [
+            if player.discord in [
                 int(player.id) for player in red_players + blu_players
             ]:
-                genned = False
-                break
-        if not genned:
+                player_matches += 1
+
+        if (not player_matches > (len(game_players) * 0.9)) or (
+            round(time.time()) - old_timestamp > 21600
+        ):
+            # This pug was likely not generated by the bot so we should add it to the searcher
+            timestamp = round(time.time()) - 7200
             print("Adding game to searcher...")
             await LogSearcher.add_searcher_game(
                 interaction.guild.id, chosen_category, game_players, timestamp